Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mathias Forsberg: re: Sow the wind, reap a storm

Most atrocities commited on both sides were against innocent civilians, to whom drunk soldiers always were very brave in all conflicts during the 20th century. OTOH those german civilians in Ostpreussen and Pommern/Schlesien that took the brunt of those soviet atrocities were not those that had commited the german atrocities in the Soviet Union. Nevertheless, I do have an understanding that such actions took place, both from a soviet, german or angloamerican perspective. The only really unjustifiaballe cases are those that the Allegemeine-SS did in Poland and the Soviet Union with their eastern helpers (the Einsatzgruppen and death camps). Those genocides were commited on a racial basis and had nothing to do with repressials against partisans or revenge, they were simply the case of the quest to establish the "master race" in Eastern Europe. Sure, the jews were the primary target, but if the KZ's had remiained well into the 1950's one can just imagine which ethnic group that had been the next target.

The discussion of battlefield atrocities is a difficult one. We judge the actions of people that lived and fought during the 1940's by our own politically correct year 2000 world view. IMHO the historically interesting thing is not wheather they did it or how many they killed, but rather why they did it. Then if it's justifiable or not is a matter of one's own subjective opinion.

/Mathias

14 October 2000, 04:22:54

71. Whitey Bulger War Crimes Oct 13, 05:38

 Arashekino re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 13, 09:13
Alex Hellmund re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 13, 22:34
 Arashekino re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 14, 18:32
Wen Jin It should be pointed out that Oct 14, 04:45
JWB re: War Crimes Oct 13, 09:32
  • Mathias Forsberg re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 14, 04:22
  •  Oleg re: War Crimes Oct 13, 21:37
     Amedeo Matteucci re: War Crimes Oct 13, 17:38
    brianb I'm with Oleg Oct 13, 23:59
     D�nes Bernad Excerpt from Ilya Ehrenburg's book 'Vojna' (no comment) Oct 14, 06:45
    Paul Spitzer re: Excerpt from Ilya Ehrenburg's book 'Vojna' (no comment) Oct 17, 01:23
    JWB re: War Crimes Oct 14, 08:23
    brianb re: War Crimes Oct 13, 21:08
    Jari Lievonen How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 10:11
     Arashekino re: How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 18:17
    Lee Dowd re: How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 18:54
    Oleg That's easy Oct 17, 19:10
    Lee Dowd re: That's easy Oct 17, 21:33
    Jari Lievonen Clarification to the question Oct 18, 09:24
    Oleg re: Clarification to the question Oct 18, 18:16
     Paul Spitzer re: Clarification to the question Oct 19, 00:50
    Peter re: Clarification to the question Oct 20, 14:52
    Oleg re: Clarification to the question Oct 20, 19:18
    Peter re: Clarification to the question Oct 21, 10:36
    Sergei K. Yeah, this really clarifies the question Oct 23, 15:48
    Jari Lievonen To Paul and Oleg Oct 19, 17:02
    Sergei K. re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 19, 18:53
    Peter re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 14:58
    Sergei K. re: To Paul and Oleg II Oct 20, 17:25
    Peter re: To Paul and Oleg II Oct 21, 10:48
    Sergei K. re: To Peter (+) Oct 23, 06:05
    Oleg re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 17:27
    Max re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 20:13
    Sergei K. re: To Max Oct 23, 07:21

    Threads navigation:  72 <<<  71  >>> 70

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 305, visitors today 239, now 193