Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mike Johnson: re: Suvorov strikes again?

Oleg,

I saw it years ago in book on intelligence collection. There were several examples listed as to why the Soviet Intelligence rated the risk of German attack as low in 1941 and medium-high in 1942. These stuck in my mind because they made sense on reflection, but were not immediately intuitive. These were the types of things that would be signs of preparations for a winter war. Soviet Intelligence showed talent converting seamingly mundane data into usable information.

I don't think the Germans prepared for a winter war because they hoped for a quick victory in the Summer or Fall. I don't buy the argument that the Winter stopped the Germans, there were an awful lot of Russians (et. al.) defending Moscow and Leningrad that I guess had something to do with it. And I do think the Germans were stretching their supply lines perhaps to the limit. And they didn't prepare for the winter.

Is not Suvurov's main claim that Stalin planned for decades (from mid-20s) to maneuver Europe into a war that would cripple the power of the status quo and then enable him to smash the existing structure in Europe and set up socialist states paralleled after his own? My take on this, if this is indeed his position, is that Stalin would and did welcome such an opportunity (breakdown of power in Europe and elsewhere), but that it would be a secondary or tertiary consideration relative to domestic economic and security issues. I also think he also wanted to open and/or maintain relations with other nations. I find it hard to believe that this long term strategy was his driving position. What is your take on this?

14 October 2000, 03:46:44

72. Whitey Bulger How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 05:42

 Arashekino re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 09:32
 Valera Potapov re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 10:38
Mike Johnson Good response, Valera Oct 13, 14:54
military re: Good response, Valera Oct 13, 18:56
Scott Schaffer His intelligence certainly didn't miss it. Oct 13, 19:26
 Oleg Suvorov strikes again? Oct 13, 21:42
Oleg re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 21:47
 military re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 22:52
  • Mike Johnson re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 03:46
  •  Men re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 23:58
     military re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 09:00
    David Woolbright re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 21:58
     Henry Oster re: Ideological war Oct 14, 09:29
     military buffer zone?! Oct 14, 23:33
    Oleg Common misconception Oct 15, 22:07
     Amedeo Matteucci re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 14, 12:34
     Arashekino re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 14, 18:38
    Oleg re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 20:47
    David Woolbright re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 14, 22:04
     military re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 22:08
     Lev re: Thunder on the Dnepr/Industrial relocation Oct 15, 00:43
    Henry Oster re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 16, 08:04
     military to Henry Oster Oct 18, 21:44
    Mike Johnson re: to Henry Oster Oct 20, 00:01
    military to Mike Johnson Oct 20, 23:31
     Henry re: Pavlov Oct 22, 00:04
    Oleg re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 15, 22:17
    Sergei K. re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 16, 04:20
    Oleg re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 16, 20:49
     military once again Oct 17, 15:41
    Oleg military, you're jumping to conclusions Oct 17, 19:42
     Lev re: once again Oct 18, 00:52
    Brad Sallows Airfield locations Oct 18, 04:03
    Sergei K. Sure, lets do it again Oct 18, 06:13
    Reigo re: Sure, lets do it again Oct 18, 14:13
    Oleg Suvorov convincing? Oct 18, 18:11
     military Oleg it's you who's jumping to conclusions Oct 18, 20:07
    Sergei K. Three sources of dislike for Suvorov Oct 18, 20:32
     military re: Three sources of dislike for Suvorov Oct 18, 22:31
     Oleg military, you haven't read Suvorov! Oct 18, 23:54
    Sergei K. Suvorov-book #12 Oct 19, 06:10
    Oleg re: Suvorov-book #12 Oct 19, 22:20
    �3, re: military, you haven't read Suvorov! (-) Oct 19, 15:53
     military re: military, you haven't read Suvorov! Oct 19, 19:11
    Sergei K. Exellent collection of webpages! Oct 19, 22:40
    military Sergey, I'll tell you the whole story Oct 20, 00:05
    Sergei K. Military: Am I too fast? Oct 20, 00:39
    military re: Military: Am I too fast? Oct 20, 21:41
     Oleg re: Exellent collection of webpages! Oct 20, 00:17
    Sergei K. Sovorov's book count -11, anybody else? Oct 19, 05:53
    (---) Sergey nothing's wrong Oct 19, 22:22
    Sergei K. re: Sergey nothing's wrong Oct 20, 00:05
     military re: Sergey nothing's wrong Oct 20, 21:44
     Arashekino re: I must agree with Sergei Oct 20, 22:46
     military That's it! (+) Oct 18, 19:32
     Arashekino re: So what's wrong with Stalin as aggressor? Oct 19, 04:08
    Mike Johnson Appreciation for info on Suvorov Oct 19, 16:58

    Threads navigation:  73 <<<  72  >>> 71

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 251, visitors today 185, now 177