Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Alex Hellmund: Irving/Hilfiger

[i]A great deal of cautiousness is indeed required when reading anything from Irving. In my opinion, Irving is a falsifier of history, who does not deserve the title of being a historian. He seriously infringes all those righteous historians and people who are struggling to tell the true story about Holocaust during WW2.[/i]

I've never read a book by David Irving, but it is important to note that no one questioned his writings until he tackled concentration camps. I also want to point out that a Jewish historian, Raoul Hilfiger, was ridiculed when he published his independent findings (lower figures) of casualties at KZs.

It is a very emotional and touchy subject.

13 October 2000, 22:27:57

70. Whitey Bulger Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 05:33

 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 15:02
  • Alex Hellmund Irving/Hilfiger Oct 13, 22:27
    Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 00:58
     Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 11:10
    Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 16:33
     Lev re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 23:38
    Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:02
    Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:38
    Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 04:18
    Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 01:00
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 11:09
  •  Mark Conrad re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 04:02
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 09:11

    Threads navigation:  71 <<<  70  >>> 69

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 336, visitors today 270, now 25