Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Amedeo Matteucci: re: War Crimes

Some things to consider:

1. Erenburg was one of the writers that collected in a book Nazis' atrocities against Soviet Hebrews. While the figure in this book (whose publication was censored by Stalin after the war) are clearly exaggerate, all the atrocities described and the witnesses' accounts are true. Probably it was his first hand knowledge of the Germans' deeds in Spain, France and USSR that led him to believe that almost all Germans supported Nazi ideas and policies.

1. This does not imply that Erenburg was a supporter of a 'kill 'em all' policy. He was one of Goebbels' favourite target. In fact the 'infamous' slogan with which he supposedly incited Red Army soldiers to rape and loot seems that was one of his 'inventions' to terrorize German civilians and had them resist at any cost. (and this not to say that raping and looting didn't happen at all)

2. On April 14, 1945 an article appeared on the Pravda, titled: 'Comrade Erenburg exaggerates'. It was writted by a certain Aleksandrov but there was the hand of Stalin behind it.
It openly criticized Erenburg for 'simplifying' things and not 'distinguish' between Germans and Nazis.
But I think that the article was more affected by political considerations (the enemies of today will be the allies of tomorrow...) than of a genuine consideration of the supposed written excesses of the journalist.

Hope this helps,

Amedeo

13 October 2000, 17:38:37

71. Whitey Bulger War Crimes Oct 13, 05:38

 Arashekino re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 13, 09:13
Alex Hellmund re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 13, 22:34
 Arashekino re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 14, 18:32
Wen Jin It should be pointed out that Oct 14, 04:45
JWB re: War Crimes Oct 13, 09:32
Mathias Forsberg re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 14, 04:22
 Oleg re: War Crimes Oct 13, 21:37
  •  Amedeo Matteucci re: War Crimes Oct 13, 17:38
    brianb I'm with Oleg Oct 13, 23:59
     D�nes Bernad Excerpt from Ilya Ehrenburg's book 'Vojna' (no comment) Oct 14, 06:45
    Paul Spitzer re: Excerpt from Ilya Ehrenburg's book 'Vojna' (no comment) Oct 17, 01:23
    JWB re: War Crimes Oct 14, 08:23
    brianb re: War Crimes Oct 13, 21:08
    Jari Lievonen How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 10:11
     Arashekino re: How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 18:17
    Lee Dowd re: How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 18:54
    Oleg That's easy Oct 17, 19:10
    Lee Dowd re: That's easy Oct 17, 21:33
    Jari Lievonen Clarification to the question Oct 18, 09:24
    Oleg re: Clarification to the question Oct 18, 18:16
     Paul Spitzer re: Clarification to the question Oct 19, 00:50
    Peter re: Clarification to the question Oct 20, 14:52
    Oleg re: Clarification to the question Oct 20, 19:18
    Peter re: Clarification to the question Oct 21, 10:36
    Sergei K. Yeah, this really clarifies the question Oct 23, 15:48
    Jari Lievonen To Paul and Oleg Oct 19, 17:02
    Sergei K. re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 19, 18:53
    Peter re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 14:58
    Sergei K. re: To Paul and Oleg II Oct 20, 17:25
    Peter re: To Paul and Oleg II Oct 21, 10:48
    Sergei K. re: To Peter (+) Oct 23, 06:05
    Oleg re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 17:27
    Max re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 20:13
    Sergei K. re: To Max Oct 23, 07:21
  • Threads navigation:  72 <<<  71  >>> 70

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 307, visitors today 241, now 194