Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mike Johnson: re:numbers

Thanks, Amedeo, for pointing out the site. I find the data presented in the spreadsheets for 4 July to 18 July most interesting. Data is for:
Voronezh Front (1st Tank Army, 5th Gds Army, 5th Gds Tank Army, 6th Gds Army, 7th Gds Army, 40th Army, 69th Army)
4th Panzer Army and Provisional Army Kempf.
Counting all PzKws (including the few PzKw Is and IIs) and the captured T-18s, the Germans had on hand on 4 July 1229 tanks and received 27 replacements. These suffered 101% casualties (193 write-offs and 1073 damaged) and a 15% write-off rate. 607 damaged tanks had been returned. The numbers are dramatic for the 89 Tigers involved (166% losses, including 8 write-offs and 140 damaged--106 of which were returned) and a 5% write-off rate. Several were knocked out, but not killed, more than once.
Soviets had 2500 tanks (KV-1s, KV-2s, T-34s, T-60s, T-70s, Lees, Stuarts, Matildas, Valentines, Churchills) on 4 July and had net replacements of 85. They suffered 88% losses (1238 write-offs and 1038 damaged) for a write-off rate of 54%. 586 damaged tanks were returned.
In terms of total equipment mentioned, vehicles and weapons, the 9759 pieces of German equipment suffered 25% losses, 33% of which were write-offs. The 22,942 pieces of Soviet equipment suffered 43% losses and had a write-off rate of 78%.
In both looking at tanks and in looking at all mentioned equipment, I recognize that it is unfair to weight everything equaly, but this does show that for some reason, the Soviet losses were considerably more likely to be write-offs than the German equipment were. Comments?

11 October 2000, 03:53:27


62. Max Debunking the Prokhorovka myth?? Oct 6, 12:29

 Nick re:Myth!? Oct 6, 14:46
 Arashekino re:Myth!? Oct 8, 03:36
Mathias Forsberg re:Myth!? Oct 8, 05:09
 Arashekino re:Myth!? Oct 8, 12:41
 Mathias Forsberg Numbers and definitions (+) Oct 8, 15:42
 Arashekino re: Numbers and definitions Oct 8, 21:31
Mathias Forsberg re: Numbers and definitions Oct 9, 16:49
 Amedeo Matteucci re:numbers Oct 8, 11:21
 Arashekino re:Wild Cards!!! Oct 9, 07:48
 Mathias Forsberg Probably missed the playoffs... (+) Oct 9, 16:39
 Arashekino re: Probably missed the playoffs... Oct 10, 08:39
Jari Lievonen Tactical situation before the battle (+) Oct 10, 10:17
Juha re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 12:44
Jari Lievonen re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 16:45
  • Mike Johnson re:numbers Oct 11, 03:53
     Wen Jin Perhaps Oct 11, 05:22
     Arashekino re: Great post! Oct 11, 05:39
  •  Paul Lakowski Ander Frankson Oct 13, 02:54
    Dave Fleet re:numbers Oct 14, 08:44

    Threads navigation:  63 <<<  62  >>> 61

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1518, visitors today 1452, now 135