Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  brianb: British, Soviet and German Armament

I always thought the KV-1 fires the same 76mm round as the T34 (equal to U.S. 75) out of a slightly longer gun than the T34, the KV I-S fires a 45 mm gun in a sleeve, the KV85 fires an 85 mm shell equivalent to the U.S. 3" gun, and IS-1 a slightly longer 85 mm or a 100 mm BS3/D10.
I would say that the 76 mm guns were about equal to the British 6 pounder and slightly inferior to the Soviet 57mm. I do know the 17 pounder (wasn't it mounted on a few Churchills in late '44/early '45?) was far more powerful than all of these except the 100mm.
As for your comments about range/top speed, I doubt the KV is superior. Top speed is far less important than reliability and somewhat less important than maneuverability. The Churchill was superior in both of these. Being slightly inferior in range does not matter much if you have good logistics support and the tank is basically good otherwise. This is not like the King tiger with its 100km max range.
As for comparisons, I would still say that a churchill w/standard armament was at least as good as a KV, and w/APDS ammo as good as a Tiger 1. (w/17 pounder, as good as a Stalin in armor/armament).

10 October 2000, 00:02:17


66.  brianb Most Underappreciated Heavy Tank of WWII Oct 8, 01:54

Mike Johnson re: Most Underappreciated Heavy Tank of WWII Oct 8, 02:20
 military I wouldn't say... Oct 8, 09:47
Mike Johnson re: I wouldn't say... (+) Oct 8, 17:47
Mike Johnson Sorry Oct 8, 18:34
David Woolbright re: I wouldn't say... Oct 8, 19:46
military but still... Oct 9, 06:35
Mike Johnson re: but still... Oct 9, 23:20
 Valera Potapov re: I wouldn't say... Oct 9, 07:59
  •  brianb British, Soviet and German Armament Oct 10, 00:02
    David Woolbright re: British, Soviet and German Armament Oct 10, 07:26
     Valera Potapov re: British, Soviet and German Armament Oct 10, 08:24
     brianb Okay, cruising speed... Oct 10, 21:44
  • Threads navigation:  67 <<<  66  >>> 65

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1477, visitors today 1411, now 107