| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
I concur that the Churchill was slow (as I stated earlier). It was designed to support foot infantry and had adequate speed for that mission, but not to compete with the faster main battle tanks.
As for road range, are you sure the 144 is km and not miles? If it were km, then the Churchill would have had one of the shortest road ranges of all UK tanks and it was noted for its longer range. My sources vary from 120-161 miles (193-259 km) for the Churchill and 225-249 km (140-155 mph) for the KV-1.Like most numbers on stats, they tend to vary somewhat by source. Road range appears to be a wash for both.
I concur that the KV-1 had a greater fording capability than the Churchill did. My sources vary for the KV-1 between 1.2 and 1.6m, while the Churchill is listed at 3�4" (1.0m). On the other hand, the Churchill may have had better trench crossing capability (9"2� to 10�, 2.8m to 3.0m) for the Churchill and (2.6m to 2.8m) for the KV-1, each source giving the Churchill a 20cm advantage.
As for firepower, I suggest you look at Valera�s posting of a Soviet engineer�s computations of penetration for various guns at history.vif2.ru/library/weapons6.html. In particular compare for the 76mm gun L/41.6 gun (F-34) which according to history.vif2.ru/guns/defin_4.html is comparable to the ZIS-5 on the KV-1. These were the longest Soviet 76mm guns (at least those posted by Valera, who posts 7 76mm guns with 5 different lengths). They are outperformed by both the 6-pounder (57mm L/50 on the Churchill, Infantry Tank Mk IV) and the 75mm L/40 on the Sherman M4A2 (and the Russian 57mm L/73). The UK 75mm L/38 was similar in performance. While I have a few technical questions about the assumptions that went into these penetration curves and the purpose the engineer developed them for, I find them roughly consistent with my own work in this area for US, UK, and German guns. Valera has saved me a lot of work for Russian guns.
When the KV was upgunned to the 85mm, it leaped ahead of the 75mm and 57mm guns on the Churchill. Note that from the Mk VII on, the configurations of the Churchill are very inconsistent between sources. Some only have VII and VIII; some go as far as IX. I have seen 17-pounders mentioned on one or another higher mark. I have seen sources that flatly deny the 17-pounder on any Churchill. I based my assessment on the lack of an operational 17-pounder on the Churchill on the development of the Black Prince (A41), which was primarily an effort to put a 17-pounder on an enlarged Churchill. I think Brian was thinking 17-pounder, which was superior to the 85mm in penetration when he made his assessment of comparability between the Churchill and KV-1.
I concur that the KV evolved more than the Churchill and that the IS series pushed this type of tank further. The Churchill was used as the basis for much of the UK specialized armor that also played a valuable role. I also still concur with Brian that the Churchill was under appreciated. I still think this is because its purpose was to support infantry, an idea counter to the notions of many a tanker during and after the war.
8 October 2000, 17:47:09
66.
brianb
Most Underappreciated Heavy Tank of WWII Oct 8, 01:54
Mike Johnson
re: Most Underappreciated Heavy Tank of WWII Oct 8, 02:20
military
I wouldn't say... Oct 8, 09:47
Mike Johnson
Sorry Oct 8, 18:34
David Woolbright
re: I wouldn't say... Oct 8, 19:46
military
but still... Oct 9, 06:35
Mike Johnson
re: but still... Oct 9, 23:20
Valera Potapov
re: I wouldn't say... Oct 9, 07:59
brianb
British, Soviet and German Armament Oct 10, 00:02
David Woolbright
re: British, Soviet and German Armament Oct 10, 07:26
Valera Potapov
re: British, Soviet and German Armament Oct 10, 08:24
brianb
Okay, cruising speed... Oct 10, 21:44
Threads navigation: 67 <<< 66 >>> 65
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1471, visitors today 1405, now 107 |