Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Arashekino: re:Myth!?

Mathias,
I saw your reply on Achtung. I think that there is a misunderstanding which you explain. Different definitions. If I define Prokharovka as occurring on just one day and you describe it as a series of battles over several days then casualties will be different. If I describe casualties as what I shoot and it stops and you only claim a casualty when you decide that it is unrecoverable then we are going to have different numbers. I agree unit histories are a source. They are not the only source. I prefer to look at the whole picture from both sides using a common criteria acceptable to all and subject the numbers to analysis not just blind acceptance because they make the Germans look like heroes. Perhaps that is what is happening but it just seems like there is too much bias against the Soviets, too little questions asked of German sources. Finally, I think the problem is the way you and these others present their information. By presenting isolated numbers you skew data that you yourself have admitted are subject to interpretation. For example, the way I presented those numbers above. What is the context. The magazine says "available" so obviously their are more unavailable in workshops. How many of those were destroyed, how many were put out of commission, repaired and put out of commision again? Basically, the issue goes back to interpretation and bias. Perhaps the Soviets knocked out 500 tanks. Perhaps they only actually destroyed 30. That does not mean they lied or the Germans and revisionists like yourselves are lying now. Finally, I still wonder about wild cards like unregistered captured vehicles. Or smaller Pzs and SPs and other armoured vehicles that overzealous anti-tankers may have killed and claimed as a tank.
Arashekino

8 October 2000, 12:41:36


62. Max Debunking the Prokhorovka myth?? Oct 6, 12:29

 Nick re:Myth!? Oct 6, 14:46
 Arashekino re:Myth!? Oct 8, 03:36
Mathias Forsberg re:Myth!? Oct 8, 05:09
  •  Arashekino re:Myth!? Oct 8, 12:41
     Mathias Forsberg Numbers and definitions (+) Oct 8, 15:42
     Arashekino re: Numbers and definitions Oct 8, 21:31
    Mathias Forsberg re: Numbers and definitions Oct 9, 16:49
  •  Amedeo Matteucci re:numbers Oct 8, 11:21
     Arashekino re:Wild Cards!!! Oct 9, 07:48
     Mathias Forsberg Probably missed the playoffs... (+) Oct 9, 16:39
     Arashekino re: Probably missed the playoffs... Oct 10, 08:39
    Jari Lievonen Tactical situation before the battle (+) Oct 10, 10:17
    Juha re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 12:44
    Jari Lievonen re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 16:45
    Mike Johnson re:numbers Oct 11, 03:53
     Wen Jin Perhaps Oct 11, 05:22
     Arashekino re: Great post! Oct 11, 05:39
     Paul Lakowski Ander Frankson Oct 13, 02:54
    Dave Fleet re:numbers Oct 14, 08:44

    Threads navigation:  63 <<<  62  >>> 61

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1508, visitors today 1442, now 124