Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Arashekino: re:Myth!?

Max,
I assume that these numbers these authors are coming up with are based on daily strenth returns. To be honest I am beginning to question the reliability of these numbers as they are always so small. I mean they are great for making the Nazis look like supermen but are they really reliable documents. Has their been any serious analysis over time to find discrepencies or errors in reporting. For example how do these reports match up to monthly or other long term reports? How do these numbers match up to what the Soviets found on the ground in wreckage? Also I have a command magazine article from March 96 and they show 2nd SS as having 498 tanks and assault guns available on the 30th of June. By the 16th of July 4 days after Prokhorovka they were down to 264 available tanks and assault guns. That is not to mention other armored vehicles which might have been labeled tanks by the Soviets like Pz 2s, Hummels, half tracks, captured vehicles etc. What I imagine is rather than a myth. You have westerners trying to debunk a myth by limiting German losses strictly to the statistics for the 12th of July and strictly to tanks and assault guns. Whereas the Soviets probably gave a general figure for the whole battle rather than just one day. Furthermore, by relating stats in such a way based on a single day. You are exposing yourself to a lot of errors. It would be interesting to see how these authors deal with these problems.
Arashekino

8 October 2000, 03:36:29


62. Max Debunking the Prokhorovka myth?? Oct 6, 12:29

 Nick re:Myth!? Oct 6, 14:46
  •  Arashekino re:Myth!? Oct 8, 03:36
    Mathias Forsberg re:Myth!? Oct 8, 05:09
     Arashekino re:Myth!? Oct 8, 12:41
     Mathias Forsberg Numbers and definitions (+) Oct 8, 15:42
     Arashekino re: Numbers and definitions Oct 8, 21:31
    Mathias Forsberg re: Numbers and definitions Oct 9, 16:49
     Amedeo Matteucci re:numbers Oct 8, 11:21
     Arashekino re:Wild Cards!!! Oct 9, 07:48
     Mathias Forsberg Probably missed the playoffs... (+) Oct 9, 16:39
     Arashekino re: Probably missed the playoffs... Oct 10, 08:39
    Jari Lievonen Tactical situation before the battle (+) Oct 10, 10:17
    Juha re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 12:44
    Jari Lievonen re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 16:45
    Mike Johnson re:numbers Oct 11, 03:53
     Wen Jin Perhaps Oct 11, 05:22
     Arashekino re: Great post! Oct 11, 05:39
  •  Paul Lakowski Ander Frankson Oct 13, 02:54
    Dave Fleet re:numbers Oct 14, 08:44

    Threads navigation:  63 <<<  62  >>> 61

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1506, visitors today 1440, now 122