Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Arashekino: re: The question...was it planned?

Whitey,
Was it planned? According to Oleg there was indeed a drought. Why couldn't a centralized communist system deal with this problem. I tend to think that the famine rather than a purposeful attempt at genocide was the result of change induced trauma. People are weak and it is difficult for them to deal with change. Paolo mentioned Native Americans. In a radically changing situation many people lost hope and committed suicide and refused to give birth. You can see the same thing in Russian now.
Another issue in planning, is the theory that Stalin starved the Ukrainian country side to build industry. I can assure all of you that this attitude was not unique. In much of Latin America this was the norm. To the present day someone in the world is starving so debts can be paid, arms can be bought etc.
Perhaps our harsh judgement of Communism comes from our wishful thinking that it would actually be better.
Arashekino

7 October 2000, 12:36:34


46.  Oleg victims of communism numbers Sep 30, 00:38

Wen Jin So what's the deal with the Ukranian famine Oct 3, 02:11
Doug re: So what's the deal with the Ukranian famine Oct 3, 03:05
 Arashekino re: I always have a question about everything! (-) Oct 3, 07:51
Wen Jin re: I always have a question about everything! Oct 3, 08:07
Paolo Marcenaro re: So what's the deal with the Ukranian famine Oct 6, 12:14
Whitey Bulger re: So what's the deal with the Ukranian famine Oct 7, 04:21
  •  Arashekino re: The question...was it planned? Oct 7, 12:36
    Stephen Comments from the other side. Oct 7, 21:04
  •  Stephen B re: Check out this website Oct 3, 22:33
     Arashekino re: Check out this website Oct 4, 08:19
     Oleg Is it me or is the link wrong? Oct 4, 17:54
     Stephen B re: oops off line.. try this instead: Oct 4, 18:38

    Threads navigation:  47 <<<  46  >>> 45

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1610, visitors today 1544, now 196