| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
A new book has just been published on the Kursk battle: "Zetterling, Niklas and Anders Frankson. Kursk 1943: A Statistical Analysis. London: Frank Cass, 2000". It relies heavily on statistics drawn both from Soviet and German archives. The book wants to debunk the many myths on the Battle of Kursk that had arisen from early Soviet and German literature and than had been passed along by earlier works from authors like Jukes, Cross, Dunnigan, and John Erickson. Here is an extract on Prokhorovka engagement:
Your Opinions on the below?
"Tank losses have often been described as equally severe for both sides but this does not match the reality. The German losses in destroyed tanks were very small compared to the losses suffered by the Red Army. The II SS-Panzer Corps lost 36 tanks and assault guns between 5 and 23 July of which at least 19 were destroyed before Prokhorovka. Accordingly, the II SS-Panzer Corps cannot have lost more than 17 during Prokhorovka.
The III Panzer Corps, which had less armour than II SS-Panzer Corps, seems to have had higher losses. During the period from 11 to 20 July, it lost 37 tanks and assault guns, but not all units of the corps took part in the Prokhorovka battle.
Rotmistrov's 5th Guards Tank Army reported that it had lost 222 T-34, 89 T-70, 12 Churchill and 11 assault guns up to 16 July. These were total write-offs. This gives a total of 334 destroyed Soviet tanks and assault guns, which can be compared to, at most, 54 German tanks and assault guns destroyed. This means the Soviet tank losses were at least six times higher. In fact, since more German units are included in this calculation than actually took part in the Prokhorovka battle, while not all Soviet units are included, the real ratio was even higher.
6 October 2000, 12:29:37
62. Max
Debunking the Prokhorovka myth?? Oct 6, 12:29
Nick
re:Myth!? Oct 6, 14:46
Arashekino
re:Myth!? Oct 8, 03:36
Mathias Forsberg
re:Myth!? Oct 8, 05:09
Arashekino
re:Myth!? Oct 8, 12:41
Mathias Forsberg
Numbers and definitions (+) Oct 8, 15:42
Arashekino
re: Numbers and definitions Oct 8, 21:31
Mathias Forsberg
re: Numbers and definitions Oct 9, 16:49
Amedeo Matteucci
re:numbers Oct 8, 11:21
Arashekino
re:Wild Cards!!! Oct 9, 07:48
Mike Johnson
re:numbers Oct 11, 03:53
Mathias Forsberg
Probably missed the playoffs... (+) Oct 9, 16:39
Arashekino
re: Probably missed the playoffs... Oct 10, 08:39
Jari Lievonen
Tactical situation before the battle (+) Oct 10, 10:17
Juha
re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 12:44
Jari Lievonen
re: Tactical situation before the battle Oct 10, 16:45
Wen Jin
Perhaps Oct 11, 05:22
Arashekino
re: Great post! Oct 11, 05:39
Paul Lakowski
Ander Frankson Oct 13, 02:54
Dave Fleet
re:numbers Oct 14, 08:44
Threads navigation: 63 <<< 62 >>> 61
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1504, visitors today 1438, now 120 |