Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Wen Jin: what's your preoccuparion with stats?

You sound like a wargamer, brianb, always looking for things "bigger, better, and faster."
Most of your analyses on the board are completely narrow-minded and one-sided. Your questions about airplanes, for instance, dealt almost entirely about top speeds and such, even though that speeds above 450mph were highly impractical for prop aircraft (simple physics: the propeller causes significant drag and instability at high speeds). Almost every single question you have asked is something akin to "can A beat B or how much armor tank C has."
This is getting ridiculous. And now you're posting a listing of best tank guns of ww2?? You must know that there is another side to war. The battle only lasts a few minutes, but the equipment has to last until the battle. Weapons are useless if they can't make it to the battlefield (King Tiger comes to mind). For example, the Soviet 76mm was an excellent gun, even though it was "inferior" to all those huge German ones. The 76 was extremely mobile and when properly set up, it was less than .8m tall. You can't say the same for the 88.
You always think that "bigger and beefier" is better. Sorry to burst your bubble, but those "super tanks" were one of the worst things Germany could have built. They were clumsy, unreliable, and uneconomical--quite a disadvantage for a nation with such limited resources. Even more useless were the "giant mortars" of Germany and the United States. Big and powerful doesn't win wars; cheap and efficient does (think T-34 and Sherman).

6 October 2000, 02:31:31


58. brianb Top 6 Tank Guns of the War Oct 5, 22:06

  •  Wen Jin what's your preoccuparion with stats? Oct 6, 02:31
    brianb re: what's your preoccuparion with stats? Oct 6, 20:10
  • Threads navigation:  59 <<<  58  >>> 57

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1547, visitors today 1481, now 153