Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Henrik Krog: re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess.

Letting the US join gives you some problems. As it was, it took Rossevelt well into1941 to even get the US involved in a limited naval war, and it took a direct attack upon it as well as a German declaration of war to get it totally into it. Also, we have to think about that the US army only had 7 divisions at the time WWII started, and for most of 1940 it would be reorganising to meet the requirements of a new kind of war. If you choose to send one or more divisions immediately, you send unexperienced regulars trained in the old ways, and at the same time deprive your army for sorely-needed regulars to build new units around.
As it was, the US had until late 1942 to rearm and re-train, and still received a battering at the hands of the weakened Africa Corps.
Also, congress would never have let Roosevelt declare war this early.
As to re-arming the French in Scandinavia, I dont think that would have occured, either. As it was in our timeline, around 100.000 (I think it was 120.000) Frenchmen were evacuated from Dunkerque to the UK, but only a few thousands volunteered to go on fighting, the rest opting for repatriation back to France. And even among those that volunteered, most were foreign legionaries, mostly Republican Spaniards.
The same happened when Syria and Lebanon were conquored. The French simply were not going to fight without their government.
As for the Scandinavians (Norwegians and Swedes) fighting alongside the Allies, I really dont know. In our alternative timeline, we let the Allies invade Norway and Sweden first. This gives us two opportunities, as both countries were neutrals, and bent on staying that way:
- Remaining neutral and letting the Allies take the Northern regions, or
- Go to war against the Allies.
The former is normally agreed to have been the Belgian and Dutch response for a like situation, and I think the initial response of Norway and Sweden would be the same, perhaps with some feigned (or real) fighting to placate the Germans. Anyway, the Swedes and Norwegians would probably have had to deploy most of their armies mobilised to the north to make it look as if they were resisting in earnest, but this would also make it easier for the Germans to move in once they opt to invade, which I fully expect them to do. Anyway, if they decide to fight, the Germans will have the industrialised areas of the south with the best infrastucture, and I dont know if the Allies would have been able to supply them in addition to their own troops and the Finns.
Henrik
Other than that, your suggestions make for

5 October 2000, 22:14:09

49. Whitey Bulger Speculative History - What if? Oct 2, 04:58

Henrik Krog Until the end of 1940 - my guess. (+) Oct 2, 14:32
David Ekstrand re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. Oct 4, 18:10
  • Henrik Krog re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. Oct 5, 22:14
  •  Henry Oster re: Speculative History - What if? Oct 10, 07:46

    Threads navigation:  50 <<<  49  >>> 48

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1586, visitors today 1520, now 181