Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


David Ekstrand: re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess.

I mostly agree with what you say, Henrik. However, if one assumes that the US joins the war rather immediately, things starts to get interesting. If we assume that they can't affect the fall of Poland, then we will at least have an American Expeditionary Force in Scandinavia (or France) which can help to hold the positions there. I think northern Sweden would have been defended stubbornly by the Brits (Churchill would probably have advised in favour of a major effort eastwards from Narvik, since he had a large interest in the area), but I'm unsure if the Soviets could have broken through northern Finland (if Sweden and Norway had sent forces to the front in Finland it would have been even more difficult).
If the Germans had invaded and occupied France and the Low Countries, and the invasion had proceeded as historically occured, I think that they might find themselves in a more difficult situation in Scandinavia than before, with US weapons rearming the evacuated troops, and quickly replenishing the ranks of the disarmed Frenchmen (if there isn't a total evacuation, as in the real case) and perahps stabilising the front in Scandinavia.

4 October 2000, 18:10:38

49. Whitey Bulger Speculative History - What if? Oct 2, 04:58

Henrik Krog Until the end of 1940 - my guess. (+) Oct 2, 14:32
  • David Ekstrand re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. Oct 4, 18:10
    Henrik Krog re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. (+) Oct 5, 22:14
  •  Henry Oster re: Speculative History - What if? Oct 10, 07:46

    Threads navigation:  50 <<<  49  >>> 48

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1585, visitors today 1519, now 180