Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


brianb: It seems no one understood my question

It seems no one paid attention to my question. I asked at what range the Tiger 1 and the JS-2 with the original nose can penetrate each other's hull. Instead I got a farflung discourse about penetration tests, shot stabilization, turret penetration, and even APFSDS ammo which was not even around until 1960 or so.
I am not an expert, but I assume that generally German armor was of much higher quality than Soviet. The Soviets used alloys and all that, but most of their armor was cast. Most German armor was forged and rolled. Tiger armor was NOT face-hardened as Mike Johnson claims but in fact homogenous. I refer you to the small but excellent work "Tiger Tanks" by Michael Green.
Of course German armor quality decreased as availability of alloys diminished, but that affected the Kingtiger more than it did the Tiger 1. I asked at what range the KwK36 can penetrate front hull of flat nose JS-2 and at what range D-25 can penetrate hull of Tiger 1. If anyone has an answer to that, I would really appreciate it. If you want to talk about fin-stabilized ammunition or projectile yaw then please start a new thread.

3 October 2000, 21:51:34


47. brianb Maximum Penetration for JS-2 and Tiger 1 Sep 30, 01:28

JWB re: Maximum Penetration for JS-2 and Tiger 1 Sep 30, 08:03
brianb Your figures are a little off Oct 1, 23:28
Mike Johnson re: Your figures are a little off (+) Oct 3, 04:06
 Paul Lakowski re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 08:00
Mike Johnson re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 17:10
 Paul Lakowski re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 20:04
 Valera Potapov re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 08:16
  • brianb It seems no one understood my question Oct 3, 21:51
    Paul Lakowski Chill out Oct 4, 02:26
     Valera Potapov Why not? Oct 5, 01:45
     brianb re: Why not? Oct 5, 17:56
  • Threads navigation:  48 <<<  47  >>> 46

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1599, visitors today 1533, now 194