| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
I suggest you consider the parameters of the various German and Soviet tests before doing this kind of comparison (or at least accepting as fact the results of such a comparison). It is my understanding that both used homogeous steel for their tests, but only the Soviets used homogeous steel on their tanks (most German tanks had face hardened armor).
The Germans meticulously tested the hardness of their test armor, while Soviet tests of test steel hardness is sketchy, although Valeriy Potapov may have some good data on that. At thicknesses about 120mm, the data I have seen the hardness is probably about a wash.
As for ammunition, I understand that the Germans used the highest quality for their tests, while the Soviets apparantly used random samples off the production line.
They used slightly different test criteria. Both required the round to completely pass through the plate a specific fraction of the time. German tests varied from 50% to 66% of the rounds to penetrate to state that the round could penetrate that thickness. Soviet tests generally required 66% to 75% of the rounds to pass through. Because of variations in the test plates' hardness (even in the same plate at different points) and in ballistic flyout the difference between 100% penetration and 0% penetration was quite wide (120mm of penetration may mean 100% below 100mm and 0% above 130mm).
Thus, Soviet tests may be slightly more conservative that German tests. But this is more than cancelled out by the Soviet use of non-penetration capped AP rounds against German face hardened armor. AP without penetration caps oftened had less than 3/4 the penetration against face hardened armor than they had against homogeneous armor.
One final point, did any of these behomoths have plates bolted or welded onto other plates to increase the thickness of the armor? If so, then the effective thickness is somewhat less than the simple addition of the thickness of the plates. When penetration begins, the armor in front of the round is pushed both into the armor and in a ring radially out from the impact point. Layered armor allows the deeper plates to support against the push into the plate, but provides virtually no support in the other direction, thus, the plates buckle faster and more penetration is possible.
3 October 2000, 04:06:58
47. brianb
Maximum Penetration for JS-2 and Tiger 1 Sep 30, 01:28
JWB
re: Maximum Penetration for JS-2 and Tiger 1 Sep 30, 08:03
brianb
Your figures are a little off Oct 1, 23:28
Paul Lakowski
re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 08:00
Mike Johnson
re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 17:10
Paul Lakowski
re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 20:04
Valera Potapov
re: Your figures are a little off Oct 3, 08:16
brianb
It seems no one understood my question Oct 3, 21:51
Paul Lakowski
Chill out Oct 4, 02:26
Valera Potapov
Why not? Oct 5, 01:45
brianb
re: Why not? Oct 5, 17:56
Threads navigation: 48 <<< 47 >>> 46
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1594, visitors today 1528, now 189 |