| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
I find this thread very interesting.
I would like to add a few comments and hear your responses to them. The UK did not produce 40mm HE armament for the 2-pounder beyond test quantities, because it really wasn't necessary. A fraction (10%-15%) of all 2-pounder tanks were built with 3in (76mm) or 3.7in (94mm) howitzers instead of the 40mm. I have never heard of these close support (CS) tanks as part of lend-lease (perhaps somebody knows about them). These populated the UK squadron (i.e., company), regimental (i.e., battalion), and brigade headquarters. Thus a typical squadron would have 3 maneuver troops (platoons) of theoretically four (but usually 2 to 3) tanks armed with 2-pounders (40mm L/52) shooting high velocity, solid shot anti-tank rounds supported by up to four CS tanks with 3.7" L/15 or 3" L/21 howitzers to provide the HE support to the maneuver troops. Note that effectiveness of HE depends on the round's weight (roughly the cube of the calibre) and very little on the length of the gun. AP (except for shaped charges) depends heavily on the gun's length (and thus the velocity) and marginally on the diameter.
Putting a 76mm L/41.6 gun on a tank designed to carry a 2-pounder probably would overload the system and might explain why the effort was abandoned.
I understand that the Soviets did not use penetration caps (APC) until after the war. They did have ballistic caps (APBC). By the time the Soviets entered the war, the primary AP rounds for the two pounder were not simple AP, but APC or APCBC, does anybody know whether the UK or US supplied AP rounds with penetration caps. Penetration caps were most effective at high impact velocities against homogenous steel armor (for all velocities) against face hardened armor that most German tanks employed.
3 October 2000, 03:29:32
45.
Kazu
Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Sep 29, 08:28
Stephen B
re: Greetings Kazu, welcome Sep 29, 22:23
brianb
re: Greetings Kazu, welcome Sep 29, 23:30
Stephen B
re: Greetings Kazu, welcome Oct 1, 01:37
Kazu
Re-armed Valentine Sep 30, 18:52
Karl Brandel
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Sep 30, 05:49
Kazu
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Sep 30, 18:57
Stephen B
re: See my reply above. (-) Oct 1, 01:26
Alexei McDonald
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 1, 00:25
Stephen B
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 1, 01:35
Karl Brandel
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 1, 07:54
brianb
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 4, 04:27
Alexei McDonald
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 10, 21:17
Stephen B
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 4, 18:42
brianb
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 4, 21:05
David Woolbright
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 6, 21:44
Stephen B
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 6, 23:04
Threads navigation: 46 <<< 45 >>> 44
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1627, visitors today 1561, now 211 |