Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Henrik Krog: Until the end of 1940 - my guess.

Well, though Britain and France were ready to attack the USSR anyway (bombing the Caucasian oilfields, intervention in Finland), I think that the Allies would have found a way to not be obliged to declare war on the USSR anyway. But if we let that go by, we can speculate.
Up to the end of 1940:
Poland would have crumbled far faster.....it had almost no forces in the East save for border guards and one or two divisions. Also, probably very few, if any Poles would have made it out to fight on in France.
After that, what happens depends on wether Germany and the USSR go on to conduct one war, or conduct separate ones. With separate wars, things in Scandinavia would have probably gone as they did in our time, but with modifications. I think Germany would have found a way to talk itself out of taking part in the Winter War, but the USSR and Germany fighting on the same side might have provided enough of a threat to let Norway and Sweden allow French and British troops to cross their territory, or at least give the Allies enough of an impetus to do it anyway, the Norwegian and Swedish troops either fighting briefly before being overwhelmed, or stepping aside, deciding to maintain neutrality in their shrunken homelands . If the Allies commit themselves here, I dont think the Germans would have dared to wage a long-range like the one they did in April 1940. Probably they would have opted to go through the Baltic instead of the North Sea, and take Sweden first instead of Norway, thus creating a more safe staging area for their ground forces, secured by the Danish islands and their fleet. The Soviet Baltic fleet might have helped here, too.
Denmark would probably have fallen just as fast as in April 1940, but the Swedish and Norwegian armies, even if not fighting the Allies, will be mobilised. Though they might not have fought for the sparsely inhabited Northern parts of their countries, or only have done so weakly, a German invasion of their Southern parts will be a fight for survival.
In Finland, the British and French troops help to keep the Soviets back, but how good they would have been at it I dont know.
If the Germans are smart, they dont let the Scandinavian theatre suck in too many troops, but conduct the invasion of France and the Low Countries much in the same manner as in our 1940. Then they can go after the Allies in Scandinavia at a later date.
If France falls, and a Vichy France develops like it did in our timeline, there will be quite a bit of confusion in Scandinavia, the British wanting to fight on with the Soviets, the French probaby wanting to go home. My guess is, the Brits disarm the French, probably passing on the arms to the Finns.
Maybe this drawn-out fighting here leads to Finland-type peace settlements with Finland, Sweden and Norway. Maybe a type 44 Finland peace settlement will oblige the Scandinavians to drive the Brits out, perhaps with German help.
The Germans and Soviets will probably insist on bases on the Norwegian coast, transit rights through Sweden and so on, but mutual German-Soviet suspicions will probably hold them in check so the terms will not be too harsh, thus allowing the Scandinavians to go on as independent countries much like Finland did after 1940. I dont know about Denmark, though....
In the Balkans, pretty much everything will have gone as it did up until the summer of 1940. Germany strengthens its position.
The Allies will have bombed the Caucasian oilfields during the winter and spring of 1940, and will probably have done some damage. Given that neither Japan nor Italy have entered the war (I assume they would not have joined it earlier than they did), perhaps the Allies will try to at least damage the Soviet Far Eastern Fleet in Vladivostok, perhaps even land some troops. Nothing that the Soviets cant drive back into the sea, though.
In the Near East, the picture is blurred. We have a Vichy Frane maintaining control over Syria and Lebanon, we have an independent Iraq, but with British bases, a totally british-controlled Palestina (Im not sure about Jordan....), a totally independent, but rather axis-friendly Iran, an independent, but rather pro-soviet Afghanistan.
If the Axis, including the Soviets, decides to invade here, a treaty dividing the area into spheres of ifluence is probably first signed (the Germans attempted something like this in 1940, but the Soviets were rather more interested in Europe). The Germans will probably want to have troops taking part, too, and the motorised and armored divisions arent freed until the fall of France. Transport to the transcaucasus (assuming the Soviets agree), re-training for fighting in the Near East, political maneuvering and so on will probably postpone any invasion of the area from the Transcaucasus into 1941. Probably some kind of peace negotiations, or at least feelers will be going on in the direction of Britain.
In the meantime, Italy has probably entered the war after the fall of France, and has been soundly defeated in Libya as in our timeline. The DAK will probably be approaching, as will the coup in Iraq, that took place in our timeline.
Of course, this is wild speculation, and any guess is as good as mine.
...will be back with 1941 later.
Henrik

2 October 2000, 14:32:06


49. Whitey Bulger Speculative History - What if? Oct 2, 04:58

  • Henrik Krog Until the end of 1940 - my guess. Oct 2, 14:32
    David Ekstrand re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. Oct 4, 18:10
    Henrik Krog re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. (+) Oct 5, 22:14
     Henry Oster re: Speculative History - What if? Oct 10, 07:46
  • Threads navigation:  50 <<<  49  >>> 48

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1584, visitors today 1518, now 180