Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Whitey Bulger: Speculative History - What if?

Greetings.
My "what if" is as follows:
What if the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August 23, 1939 had been slightly reworded, and the German and Soviet invasions of Poland occured together, and not 17 days apart as happened in reality?
Would Britain and France, allies of Poland and guarantors of their security, have declared war on BOTH Germany and Soviet Union?
Given both the British and French overestimation of their military abilities in 1939, I believe they would have.
What would Germany's "anti-Red" allies in Italy and Japan have done?
Would this have made the war one of "the Free World" democracies against totalitarianism? If so, would this have prompted some kind of idealistic "Wilsonian" movement in the US, with America joining the war earlier than December 1941?
For Poland, would it have been spared the destruction it suffered as a battleground in 1944-1945?
Who would have won?
Would the post-World War Two globe have been a world divided between Hitler and Stalin (shudder)? All due to change in the date the Red Army would invade Poland in September 1939 - which would have seemed a rather minor detail at the time.
Whitey Bulger

2 October 2000, 04:58:20

  • 49. Whitey Bulger Speculative History - What if? Oct 2, 04:58

    Henrik Krog Until the end of 1940 - my guess. (+) Oct 2, 14:32
    David Ekstrand re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. Oct 4, 18:10
    Henrik Krog re: Until the end of 1940 - my guess. (+) Oct 5, 22:14
     Henry Oster re: Speculative History - What if? Oct 10, 07:46
  • Threads navigation:  50 <<<  49  >>> 48

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1583, visitors today 1517, now 178