| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Dear Stephen,
of course, this conversion was made on a 2-pdr Valentine as, IIRC in December 1941 there were no 6-pdr armed vehicles produced let alone shipped to the Soviets (8^).
So we are not taking about putting a larger gun in the (larger turret) of a Valentine Mk. VIII/IX but into the small two men Mk. II/IV turret. Although the turret race diameters are in both versions the same the 6-pdr was mounted considerably forward, non the less leaving a very cramped turret. Even the turret MG had to be left away in the Mk. VIII/IX due to severe space restrictions. Not the least problem is also the length of the gun travel during firing. At all elevations the gun breech must not hit the turret race and leave enough space to eject a cartridge case. So even a similar calibre gun with a longer recouperating distance could not be fitted into a given turret.
The main reason to rearm British tanks was also not to give them a better anti tank capability as the 2-pdr and the 45mm were roughly equal in this respect but an ability to fire HE. Why the Soviets abandoned the idea of regunning is still unclear. Perhaps they finally considered the co-ax machinegun sufficient. I also don�t know presently if the RKKA ever received British HE ammo for the 2-pdr as this type was also in very short supply within British units.
6-pdr armed Valentines Mk- VIII and IX had been shipped in large numbers but also lacked HE ammunition. It is also interesting to note that the �slow� Valentine was even at wars end was deployed to cavalry mechanised groups
Concerning the Matilda memory failed me when I stated that a prototype was fitted with the local 45mm. During December 1941, after an order by the GKO, the Grabin design bureau of Zavod No. 92 started work for re-gunning the Matilda with the 76.2mm ZIS-5 and a DT co-axial machine gun (Factory index ZIS-96 or F-96). During the same month a prototype was finished and was sent for trails to Moscow.
Kind regards,
Karl Brandel
1 October 2000, 07:54:27
45.
Kazu
Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Sep 29, 08:28
Stephen B
re: Greetings Kazu, welcome Sep 29, 22:23
brianb
re: Greetings Kazu, welcome Sep 29, 23:30
Stephen B
re: Greetings Kazu, welcome Oct 1, 01:37
Kazu
Re-armed Valentine Sep 30, 18:52
Karl Brandel
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Sep 30, 05:49
Kazu
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Sep 30, 18:57
Stephen B
re: See my reply above. (-) Oct 1, 01:26
Alexei McDonald
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 1, 00:25
Stephen B
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 1, 01:35
Karl Brandel
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 1, 07:54
Mike Johnson
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 3, 03:29
brianb
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 4, 04:27
Alexei McDonald
re: Armament upgrade for Lend-lease tanks Oct 10, 21:17
Stephen B
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 4, 18:42
brianb
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 4, 21:05
David Woolbright
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 6, 21:44
Stephen B
re: 90 mm vs 122 vs 88 Oct 6, 23:04
Threads navigation: 46 <<< 45 >>> 44
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1626, visitors today 1560, now 210 |