Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Brent: re: Plane specs as opposed to reality

brianb states:
>Does that explain why the Me262 jet (by far the fastest aircraft of the war) was so poor in >meneuverability that P 51s could beat it?
First off: The 262 was not the fastest plane of the war. It only went 540mph/869kph. The Me-163 was faster at 593mph/955kph. Both of which were slower than the Gloster Meteor which went 603mph/965kph.
Second: You continue to let stats get in the way of reality. Sure the 262 was faster than the P-51. Now pretend you are a Mustang pilot and it's your job to knock them down. How do you do it? You use your strengths against their weaknesses. Where is the 262 vulnerable? During take offs and landings it can't accellerate like a P-51. So you bounce them at the airfield. Which is what happened. In fact, the first air to air jet kill was almost another air to ground kill. Apparently the 262 had just lifted off when it was caught by the P-51's gun burst. I doubt very many 262's were knocked down in an actual dog fight. Their purpose was to destroy bombers, not to get tangled up with fighters.
Please read a book and quit basing your opinions on the stat sheets in your combat sim games. None of the questions you ask are difficult to answer. The answers are easily found in books or even websites. However, I am glad of your interest in aviation history.

27 September 2000, 22:10:30


20.  Brent Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 01:12

Mike Jasinski re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 02:53
 Stephen B re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 17:05
 Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 19:33
Brent re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 20:17
 Daniel Olsson Well, almost... Sep 15, 23:19
brianb re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 21:29
 Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 21:47
brianb re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 22:27
Brent Note to Brianb Sep 19, 22:50
brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 19, 23:28
Christer Bergstrom re: Note to Brianb Sep 20, 00:20
Franek Grabowski re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 17:37
Brent re: Note to Brianb Sep 20, 01:36
brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 01:39
 Daniel Olsson re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 08:31
brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 22:36
 Arashekino re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 22, 02:53
Wen Jin I doubt that most US planes could actually reach their ideal max (-) Sep 22, 08:16
brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 22, 21:02
Wen Jin re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 23, 02:56
brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 25, 21:09
Mike Johnson re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 25, 23:38
brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 00:50
  • Brent re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 22:10
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 23:11
    Brent re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 19:34
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 21:29
  •  Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 19:31
    Brent re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 20:24
    Bob Potter re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 21:46
    Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 23:22
    Christer Bergstrom Losses in Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 17, 20:07

    Threads navigation:  21 <<<  20  >>> 19

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1845, visitors today 1779, now 186