Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Karl Brandel: re: US guns at Makensia?

Alex,
interesting finding. If those guns were sent under Lend-Lease they could be either the:
+ Gun, Anti-Tank, 37mm, M3;
+ Gun, Anti-Tank, 57mm, M1;
+ Gun, Automatic, 37mm, M1A2;
+ Gun, Automatic, 40mm, M1 (Bofors); or the
+ Gun, Anti-Aircraft, 90mm, M1A1.
They were all sent under the First Moscow Protocol (October �41 until June �42) so they all could be ready for Manstein�s Crimean campaign. As you said they were heavy types I would vote for the 90mm AAA. Of course, there is the possibility that those guns you mentioned are other U.S. types bought before the war, but I don�t no enough about this topic to say anything pro or con.
This is indeed a very interesting topic as the use of Lend-Lease guns in Soviet service is, in contrast to AFV�s and tactical vehicles completely neglected in the Soviet or Russian literature. The only reference I have about Allied guns used by the Soviets is:
�40 mm Angliyskaya protivotankovayapushka: Kratkoe opisanie� (40mm English Anti Tank Gun: A short description), Glavnoe Artilleriyskoe Upravlenie Krasnoy Armii, Voenizdat NKO SSSR, Moskva, 1942. But this is only a TM and contains nothing about the guns used in action.
BTW, to which German book or source are you referring ?
Kind regards,
Karl Brandel

25 September 2000, 15:32:42


41. Alex Hellmund US guns at Makensia? Sep 25, 05:45

  • Karl Brandel re: US guns at Makensia? Sep 25, 15:32
    John Fluker re: US guns at Makensia? Sep 25, 16:54
     Men re: US guns at Makensia? Sep 25, 17:59
    Alex Hellmund Fixed, not mobile... Sep 26, 04:08
     Stephen B re: 305 mm Sep 27, 01:23
    Mike Johnson re: 305 mm Sep 27, 19:21
    Alex Hellmund Battleship "Retvizan" armament Sep 27, 19:58
    Alexei McDonald Battleship Retvizan's armament Sep 28, 07:42
    Alex Hellmund Ok, so its not the Retvizan Sep 29, 06:58
     Stephen B re: oops, thow art correct. n/t Sep 28, 18:50
  • Threads navigation:  42 <<<  41  >>> 40

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1661, visitors today 1595, now 228