Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mike Johnson: re: Value of Lend-lease tanks?

I, in general, agree with the responses above, but was surprised by comments about the Valentine in particular (recon tank, main battle tank, Mk XI with 17-pounder). One comment to add is it seems that US-built tanks were sensitive to the exact composition of fuel.
The Valentine as a recon or a main battle tank is interesting given its maximum speed of 15 mph (24 kph). In UK service, it was the Infantry Tank Mk III and primarily used to support infantry attacks. Its design speed was no more than what would allow it to operate effectively with foot infantry (including short sprints).
The T-50 page on this site gives industrial disruption caused by the German attack, the availability of the Valentine, and lack of engine availability as reasons for killing the T-50 program. It is a chicken-egg issue (did the availability of the Valentine kill the T-50 or did the demise of the T-50 lead to calls for the Valentine?).
It is my understanding that the Valentine Mk XI had a short 75mm gun and not the long 76mm 17-pounder, with a major difference in effectiveness.
One question I have is when did the first lend-lease tanks arrive in the Soviet Union? I read somewhere that UK-built tanks (Matildas?, Valentines?) surprised German forces in the summer (September?) 1941. No site on lend lease tanks I have seen mention this. It seems rather quick for such tanks to arrive. I was wondering if anybody had any information about how soon lend lease tanks arrived.

20 September 2000, 18:00:26


33.  M.D. Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 19, 22:39

Brent re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 19, 23:03
John Fluker re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 00:48
 Stephen B re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? (+) Sep 19, 23:39
 Men re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 00:51
  • Mike Johnson re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 18:00
     Stephen B re: Reply to Mike Sep 20, 18:21
    Alexei McDonald re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 22, 21:37
     Stephen B re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 18:15
    Mike Johnson re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 20:53
     David Woolbright re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 08:10
    Lev re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 13:05
     Stephen B re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks and time period considerations? Sep 22, 23:01
    Lee Dowd re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 28, 23:44
     Lev re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 29, 15:15
     Lee Dowd re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 29, 23:27
  • Brad Sallows Valentines and Shermans Sep 20, 23:29
    Bob Potter re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 02:58
     Men re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 05:21
     Bob Potter re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 22, 00:32

    Threads navigation:  34 <<<  33  >>> 32

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1707, visitors today 1641, now 249