Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Brent: re: Note to Brianb

(sigh)
>But don't you think that by '45 most Western aces were better than most German aces?
Nope! Galland and his crew could have darn near anyone for lunch. Assuming he had fuel. If you were a German ace in '45 you were someone who deserved respect from enemies. I don't care what I was flying but I wouldn't engage Galland's circus unless I had to. I would stay healthier that way.
>Plus, a P51H totally beats a TA152.
I don't have stats in front of me but I doubt it. Everything in aviation is a trade off. All aircraft are comprimises. The two aircraft are going to have strengths and weaknesses. Use two equal pilots to battle at below 5,000 feet and your Mustang might win. Incease the altitude to 20,000 or higher the FW might win. Add the variable of pilot experience to the battle and take your pick. Either could win or lose.
Was the H operational early enough in '45? I don't know if they were ever deployed in the ETO. I do know the Ta-152 saw very limited service. Just like the D series of FW-190.
Another thing to consider: In reality not many American aces fooled around with dog fighting. It was strictly "boom and zoom". Gabreski or Johnson described it as murder. Just sneaking up on a guy and letting him have it. If these guys snuck up on you, it wouldn't matter what you were flying.
Personally if I had to pick I'd choose a P-47. The best survivability and you can always dive away and break off the engagement. Nothing was faster in a dive than the P-47.
Random thought: I never understood why the Russians rejected the P-47 but kept the P-39.
Read more,
Brent

20 September 2000, 01:36:20


20.  Brent Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 01:12

Mike Jasinski re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 02:53
 Stephen B re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 17:05
 Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 19:33
Brent re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 20:17
 Daniel Olsson Well, almost... Sep 15, 23:19
brianb re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 21:29
 Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 21:47
brianb re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 22:27
Brent Note to Brianb Sep 19, 22:50
brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 19, 23:28
Christer Bergstrom re: Note to Brianb Sep 20, 00:20
Franek Grabowski re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 17:37
  • Brent re: Note to Brianb Sep 20, 01:36
    brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 01:39
     Daniel Olsson re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 08:31
    brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 22:36
     Arashekino re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 22, 02:53
    Wen Jin I doubt that most US planes could actually reach their ideal max (-) Sep 22, 08:16
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 22, 21:02
    Wen Jin re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 23, 02:56
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 25, 21:09
    Mike Johnson re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 25, 23:38
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 00:50
    Brent re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 22:10
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 23:11
    Brent re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 19:34
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 21:29
  •  Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 19:31
    Brent re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 20:24
    Bob Potter re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 21:46
    Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 23:22
    Christer Bergstrom Losses in Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 17, 20:07

    Threads navigation:  21 <<<  20  >>> 19

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1831, visitors today 1765, now 192