Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Franek Grabowski: kill ratios

I think you don't know what are you talking about. Your kill ratios are actually claim-to-loss ratios. Claims are the estimates what the intel thought were actuall losses of the enemy. They shouldn't be mistaken with actuall losses of the enemy. Claims sometimes were equall to actuall losses but such situations occured rarely, usually they were to high two or three or more times.
Regarding kills against Germans in 1944. Most of the kills were done by US pilots (RAF fighters flew mostly tactical support operations) but they're overclaimed in ratio 20-50%. Just get two books. Over the Beaches covering Allied claims & losses over Normandy and Luftwaffe en face du debarquement Allies giving similar numbers for Jagdwaffe. You'll find that usually Americans were hardly beaten by those Krauts. German problem was that for each lost experte they had nothing to replace. Americans could sent another group of pilots for each one lost. They just overfled Germans. (Of course we must remember that RAF claims for the period 1944-45 were pretty close to German losses, therefore no straight comparison with Americans is possible)
Regarding Soviet pilots. Opinions are various, I think Christer may give some info on that. Nevertheless the one must remember that Soviets flew with small formations on quite low level, usually on outmoded A/C, therefore being sitting ducks for German aces. They (Soviets) were unable to chase them, as their A/C were manouverable but to slow and with poor vertical performances. The one also must remember that it was in mid 1943(!) when quantities of modern types (L-L ones, Yaks, Laggs and Migs) equalled those of older ones (I-16s & I-153s). It's no wonder Soviets were beaten so hardly in conditions they had to fight.
Otherwise training level seems to be poor in Soviet aviation in 1940s & 1950s. There was major improvement, when Polish People AF mobilised several Polish pre-war and RAF airmen in 1957, effects of improved training were visible for example during Arab-Israeli wars where Polish-trained Jewes were beating Russian-trained Arabics.
Franek Grabowski

20 September 2000, 00:52:37


24. brianb Ivan K vs. USAF Sep 17, 00:58

 Daniel Olsson re: Ivan K vs. USAF Sep 17, 10:14
Christer Bergstrom Ivan Kozhedub actually knocked down two P-51s in a single combat Sep 17, 19:54
Christer Bergstrom Message to Daniel Olsson Sep 17, 20:09
brian b western vs soviet pilots Sep 18, 23:10
Jorge Visca re: western vs soviet pilots Sep 19, 01:17
 David Woolbright re: western vs soviet pilots Sep 19, 01:35
Wen Jin Do you have something against Soviets? Sep 19, 03:52
 Arashekino re: Do you have something against Soviets? Sep 19, 04:19
 Wen Jin 10:1? more like 3:1 (-) Sep 19, 05:54
Wen Jin Soviets vs. USAF, that is (-) Sep 19, 05:57
Lee Dowd re: Soviets vs. USAF, that is Sep 19, 16:18
 Brent re: Soviets vs. USAF, that is Sep 19, 17:55
Oleg re: Soviets vs. USAF, that is Sep 19, 18:40
Lee Dowd re: Soviets vs. USAF, that is Sep 19, 19:43
brianb red vs western pilots Sep 19, 21:18
Christer Bergstrom USAAF fighter kill ratio over the Germans Sep 20, 00:11
  • Franek Grabowski kill ratios Sep 20, 00:52
     Pqul Spitzer re: kill ratios Sep 28, 02:15
     Wen Jin I don't think that "Kraut" is appropriate for this board Sep 20, 02:12
    Wen Jin Info on Soviet Aces in Korea Sep 20, 02:54
     Jorge Visca The link posted above is recommended! (-) Sep 20, 04:34
     Brent Clarification: re: Soviets vs. USAF Sep 19, 21:55
    brianb re: Do you have something against Soviets? Sep 19, 21:27
     Alex Wood re: Do you have something against Soviets? Sep 19, 22:17
    brianb Israeli aces Sep 19, 22:25
    Oleg re: Israeli aces Sep 19, 23:28
    brianb re: Israeli aces Sep 19, 23:31
    Paul Spitzer Israeli pilots on Saturday Oct 6, 02:39
    Paul Spitzer re: Israeli aces Oct 6, 03:35
    FAM TUAN re: Do you have something against Soviets? Oct 18, 11:46
     Brent German & Eastern European Volunteers in Korea Sep 20, 04:13
     Jorge Visca re: German & Eastern European Volunteers in Korea Sep 20, 04:43
     Arashekino re: Okay! I'll try to find the source. (-) Sep 20, 18:33
     DAVID re: Okay! I'll try to find the source. Oct 18, 11:54
  • Threads navigation:  25 <<<  24  >>> 23

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1772, visitors today 1706, now 253