Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Christer Bergstrom: re: Note to Brianb

"I actually meant an Fw A/F versus a P-51D."
Of course, a large number of P-51Ds were shot down by German airmen piloting an Fw 190 A. I must have misunderstood your question? And there were Soviet airmen piloting I-15s who shot down Bf 109 Fs...
"But don't you think that by '45 most Western aces were better than most German aces?"
Definitely not. In 1945, there were German aces who had amassed combat experience from more than one thousand sorties each, including hundreds of dogfights. By the end of the war, those guys stood at the peak of their success. But of course, the majority of them operated on the Eastern Front...
To the contrary, I'd say that in 1945, there were no "Western" aces who could match the best German and Soviet aces.

20 September 2000, 00:20:41


20.  Brent Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 01:12

Mike Jasinski re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 02:53
 Stephen B re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 17:05
 Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 19:33
Brent re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 15, 20:17
 Daniel Olsson Well, almost... Sep 15, 23:19
brianb re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 21:29
 Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 21:47
brianb re: Yak vs. P-51? Sep 19, 22:27
Brent Note to Brianb Sep 19, 22:50
brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 19, 23:28
  • Christer Bergstrom re: Note to Brianb Sep 20, 00:20
    Franek Grabowski re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 17:37
    Brent re: Note to Brianb Sep 20, 01:36
    brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 01:39
     Daniel Olsson re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 08:31
    brianb re: Note to Brianb Sep 21, 22:36
     Arashekino re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 22, 02:53
    Wen Jin I doubt that most US planes could actually reach their ideal max (-) Sep 22, 08:16
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 22, 21:02
    Wen Jin re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 23, 02:56
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 25, 21:09
    Mike Johnson re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 25, 23:38
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 00:50
    Brent re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 22:10
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 23:11
    Brent re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 19:34
    brianb re: Plane specs as opposed to reality Sep 27, 21:29
  •  Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 19:31
    Brent re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 20:24
    Bob Potter re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 21:46
    Daniel Olsson re: Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 15, 23:22
    Christer Bergstrom Losses in Yak vs. P-38 Engagement Sep 17, 20:07

    Threads navigation:  21 <<<  20  >>> 19

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1832, visitors today 1766, now 193