Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Stephen B: re: Value of Lend-lease tanks?

This has been a rather controversial subject in the recent past. Things that I have picked up in my reading are:
1. The British Valentine was continued in production by the Canadians at Soviet request into 1943, for a total of about 1000 supplied from the Brits and 2000 from the Canadians (not possitive about the exact numbers at the moment). I have read that the Soviets liked them as recon tanks.
2. The M3 Stuarts were valued for their reliability and made fine recon tanks and were comparable to the T-60 and T-70 tanks, and better than the T-26's as far as reliability.
3. The M3 Lee's are much derided though were probabaly a better infantry support tank than they are given credit for, in overall reliability and crew coordination and could deal with a Pz III fine but was at a disadvantage to the Pz IV.
4. The Churchill was slow and undergunned (6 lb) for a tank its weight, though the British liked them and used some into the 1950's. It had very good armor protection for its time, I think comparible to the KV.
5. The M4A2 diesel Sherman, according to Col. Loza's books were very much appreciated. About 2000 with the short 75 mm gun were sent and about 2000 with the 76 mm long gun (including about 200 M4A2's with the HVSS (easy eight) suspension). The 75 gun was comparible to the Soviet 76 mm and had a good HE shell. The 76 mm gun was comparible to the Soviet 85 in AP though not in HE shell. The Sherman did not have as good cross country mobility as the T-34 but was more mechanically reliable. Its big advantage was the turret crew layout. With a seperate gunner the Sherman crew could react quicker and coordinate better than the T-34/76. The Sherman was also much quieter than the T-34.
I understand that most all the US and UK tanks came with receivers and transmitters, something that most early soviet tanks lacked. ood radio communications can make a world of difference in a confusing battles. I have read that most Soviet tank radios were supplied by Canada and the US.
Overall I think that the idea of the Soviets dismissing most allied tanks as no good is old cold war propaganda.

19 September 2000, 23:39:17


33.  M.D. Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 19, 22:39

Brent re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 19, 23:03
John Fluker re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 00:48
  •  Stephen B re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 19, 23:39
     Men re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 00:51
    Mike Johnson re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 18:00
     Stephen B re: Reply to Mike Sep 20, 18:21
    Alexei McDonald re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 22, 21:37
     Stephen B re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 18:15
    Mike Johnson re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 20, 20:53
     David Woolbright re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 08:10
    Lev re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 13:05
     Stephen B re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks and time period considerations? Sep 22, 23:01
    Lee Dowd re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 28, 23:44
     Lev re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 29, 15:15
     Lee Dowd re: Ratio of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 29, 23:27
    Brad Sallows Valentines and Shermans Sep 20, 23:29
    Bob Potter re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 02:58
     Men re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 21, 05:21
     Bob Potter re: Value of Lend-lease tanks? Sep 22, 00:32
  • Threads navigation:  34 <<<  33  >>> 32

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1705, visitors today 1639, now 249