| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
I have followed with interest the debates on losses (particularly German losses) on this site. I have not participated in these debates until now for two reasons: I don't have great confidence in the losses data in my sources (as they very substantially) and because I believe the point of these discussions is to prove one or the other assertion (German superiority or Soviet parity).
With these reservations, I have decided to throw in my two cents.
KIA, WIA, and MIA numbers are counted originally at the lowest levels and are aggregated up the chain of command. These are the initial numbers.
KIA is pretty straight forward. Either the reporting unit has a body or a positive identification by a fellow soldier. It is a statistical small event when somebody reported KIA turns up alive.
WIA is much more complex. Some WIA never leave their assigned unit. Some enter the medical evacuation system, but return quickly to their unit. Some spend longer in recovery and then enter the replacement system for assignment to a new unit. Some remain hospitalized for some time. Some are assigned non-combat duties (as they are not fit for combat) in the large supporting establishments that ensured that ammunition, supplies, and personnel moved forward to the combat units, some were discharged for disabilities, and some died while under medical care. KIA numbers generally do not reflect those who died under medical care. DOW numbers typically vary from 50% to 100% of KIA numbers.
MIA is almost as complex. Personnel not present in their unit after action, without a positive KIA report are reported as MIA. They could be lost and subsequently return to their unit. They could be be captured and thus become POWs. They could desert. They could be unknown KIAs. Another complication is that companies and battalions (combat echelons) often lost contact with their superiors for a couple of days. If contact is not reestablished in a week or two, the parent unit would report the whole unit as MIA. Late in the war, whole German divisions became MIAs.
Units may experience non-combat related losses as well. Accidents and serious illnesses may result in deaths or incapacitations. The Vietnam War has been mentioned in these debates. Official US Army deaths include 31,000 combat deaths (KIA and DOW) and 7,000 died of disease or accident. Personnel in combat units are also arrested and removed from their units (often for insubordination or desertion). This source is probably a couple of percent, so it may not be that significant. (German and Soviet forces may have had higher arrest rates, but I don't have the data to back up this assertion)
Initial WIA:KIA ratios are often 5 or 10:1, but the ratio of (WIA - DOW - less significant wounds): (KIA + DOW) could be 2-3 : 1. For example, suppose 7 casualties occured in a unit as follows:
1 KIA, 1 WIA who later died, 1 WIA discharged for wounds, 1 WIA convalesced and sent to another unit, 1 WIA treated and returned to unit, 1 WIA treated by medic and retained in unit, and 1 MIA captured and returned after the war.
The initial ratio would be 5 WIA to 1 KIA, but the wounded to dead ratio would be 4 to 2 or 2:1. Despite 7 reported loss, the loss to the unit would be 5 and the loss to the field forces would be 4.
When comparisons are made between loss ratios, lets make sure we are talking about equivalent losses.
19 September 2000, 15:56:26
31. mars
Geman WWII casualties Sep 19, 01:31
Jari Lievonen
re: Geman WWII casualties Sep 19, 10:43
Max
re: Geman WWII casualties Sep 19, 11:02
Mathias Forsberg
re: Geman WWII casualties Sep 19, 12:32
Oleg
Thanks for interesting info Sep 19, 18:32
Max
re: Thanks for interesting info Sep 19, 20:19
Pat
re: Geman WWII casualties Sep 22, 05:39
Oleg
re: Thanks for interesting info Sep 19, 22:51
Threads navigation: 32 <<< 31 >>> 30
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1729, visitors today 1663, now 253 |