Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


John Fluker: Staged photos?

Many of the photos are quite evidently staged. I make the assuption, for example, when the picture is taken from slightly in front of an otherwise reasonable-appearing position or formations, and when the photo shows tanks charging into battle carrying tank descents, but the camera level is below the turret rings of the tanks. The most extreme example of an obvious posed incident appears in several of my books, showing Red infantrymen charging past a smoking PzKv IV (kurtz). Some copies of the picture have not been trimmed, and therefore show a man standing casually at one side holding a clipboard.
There is more logic to this than in the case of staged photography on the Western Front. I have been told that absolutely no photographic equipment was manufactured in the USSR during WW II (though I have not been able to confirm it - anybody?) Apparently, there were standing instructions not to risk the cameras.

16 September 2000, 17:47:33


18. John Fluker "A bullet's a crazy bitch - the bayonet is a good lad" Sep 14, 16:21

 Arashekino re: So you are suggesting that Red Army fought without bullets? Sep 16, 07:48
  • John Fluker Staged photos? Sep 16, 17:47
    David Woolbright re: So you are suggesting that Red Army fought without bullets? Sep 17, 03:49
  • Threads navigation:  19 <<<  18  >>> 17

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1860, visitors today 1794, now 166