Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Mathias Forsberg: Let me create my own theories, please...

"You said you don't develop theories based on these numbers."
When did I wrote this??? I wrote that I was suprised that the german war casualties were so low they were according to the german documents.
"Throwing out numbers for just the sake of numbers is just pissing in the wind."
Pissing in the wind is nice, if the wind comes from behind... I think you completely missed the point here, I just don't throw out numbers. Instead I've tried to make people stop throwing out numbers, especially those based on nothing but what's "reasonable". What we were discussing were just numbers, not theories. I can give you 30.000 theories of mine regarding WWII (like should the attack on Dunqerque continued, should the soviets have evacuated the Kiev pocket in 1941, should the germans have attacked at Kursk at all etc) but when it comes to raw numbers you need facts, not theories. Of course you're free to interpret those numbers in any way, but the issue here were the numbers themselves.
Then I tried to contribute by posting Zetterling's researched numbers (which I clearly state weren't mine) and still you don't have nothing more constructive to write then I base my numbers on the "Super Race Theory". I don't know what to say...
I like numbers based on primary sources, wheather they are reasonable or not. And when you research german casualties, those numbers should come from german primary sources, not soviet estimates. When you research soviet casualties, those numbers should come from soviet primary sources, not german estimates.
And I really don't see why Hitler would postpone the making of the MP 44 just becasuse he was fooled to believe the german casualties were too low. The major reason (although, like in many cases, not the only one) was that the ammo to the MP/StG 44 were 7.92mm "kurz" (short), meaning it was another type of ammo than the regular 7.92mm ammo. Hitler believed in a powerful cartidge since his WWI experiances, and also feared the supply situation would be too difficult with three major types of ammo (7.92mm, 7.92mm K and 9mm).
Your theory (unlike me, you wrote thisone yourself) wouldn't for example explain why he wanted the ME-262 to be an attack aircraft instead of a fighter. I agree though that the psycological situation in the Bunker would be intresting to investigate. The problem is that few survived (Speer being the most important source) and especially during 1945 it's very hard proving that were actually there meeting Hitler and even more hard proving that they (and Hitler) said what they've claimed they said.
Of course, this is my Nazi-Aryan view... I bet you have a much better one...
/Mathias

16 September 2000, 16:27:43


15. Oleg Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 21:43

 Wen Jin re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 22:50
Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 23:06
Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 09:59
 Arashekino re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 11:03
 Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 12:15
Lee Dowd re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 21:58
 Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 13:03
Oleg Thanks for the figures Sep 14, 18:14
 Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 14, 18:27
 Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 14, 19:21
Max addendum Sep 14, 19:30
Oleg re: addendum Sep 14, 23:30
Max re: addendum Sep 15, 09:49
Oleg Are you serious?!!! Sep 15, 20:38
Wen Jin re: addendum Sep 15, 02:36
Max re: addendum Sep 15, 09:57
Wen Jin Ridiculous Sep 15, 19:24
Pat re: 700000 women in German military !! Sep 18, 22:42
Frank DeLaglio re: Total German losses in WW2 (+) Sep 16, 00:25
Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 18, 18:46
 Mathias Forsberg Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 19, 02:42
Oleg re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 19, 18:54
 Lee Dowd re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 19, 19:45
David Woolbright re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 21, 08:20
Mike Johnson re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 22, 16:37
Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 19, 09:01
Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 19, 19:07
 Mathias Forsberg Krivosheev's number too high? Sep 20, 03:49
Oleg Here's complete Krivosheyev's data Sep 20, 18:39
Mike Johnson re: Here's complete Krivosheyev's data Sep 22, 16:46
Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 20, 13:21
Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 22:54
Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 00:28
Wen Jin re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 03:11
 Arashekino re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 04:31
 Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 12:51
 Arashekino re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 15, 17:19
Wen Jin re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 15, 19:36
  •  Mathias Forsberg Let me create my own theories, please... Sep 16, 16:27
     Arashekino re: Let me create my own theories, please... Sep 16, 17:01
     Mathias Forsberg Documents, KIA and Bagration Sep 16, 18:05
  • Denes Bernad re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 06:46
     Oleg Thank you Sep 14, 18:16
     Frank DeLaglio re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 14, 21:37
     Frank DeLaglio New Try Sep 14, 21:47
    Oleg re: New Try Sep 14, 23:37
     Arashekino re: New Try Sep 15, 04:11
     Mathias Forsberg Archival dates Sep 15, 12:50
     Max re: New Try Sep 15, 09:33
    Wen Jin So you're saying that everything Soviet is a lie? (-) Sep 15, 19:26
    Max re: So you're saying that everything Soviet is a lie? Sep 15, 19:50
    Oleg Who is that researcher? Sep 15, 20:44
    Max re: Who is that researcher? Sep 15, 21:50
    Oleg re: Who is that researcher? Sep 16, 04:53
     Denes Bernad re: New German book on total German losses in WW2 Sep 19, 00:04
    brianb why is it so hard to believe Sep 19, 22:30

    Threads navigation:  16 <<<  15  >>> 14

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1910, visitors today 1844, now 123