Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Wen Jin: Offensives don't mean higher casulaties

By the end of the war, Soviet tactics were in many cases superior (eg. use of lightning bombardment, assault groups, forward battalions, assault engineers); it was often the horrendous quality of 2nd-echelon troops that spawns those "stupid Soviets" myths. Hitler's order to "stand fast" only resulted in a first echelon bypass of strongpoints. BTW, If you believe the 300,000 Soviet casualties in Berlin, it would actually mean that the Soviets had a favorable kill ratio there, since by the end of the war the KIA/WIA ratio was 1:3 or better (see Mathias's figures of the Vistula-Oder op).
Offensives can often result in favorable casulaty rates. Control of the field means that you can retrieve your wounded, while the enemy's wounded bleed to death. The Vistula-Oder operation saw a German death rate of at least 4:1, so that puts your theory to hell.
Oh, yeah, I don't know where you live, but the USA had 150,000 wounded in Vietnam (Dept of Defense Figures). Where do you get 500,000? I still don't buy your assumptions about killed/wounded ratios.

16 September 2000, 15:50:37


21. Karl Brandel Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 09:05

 Arashekino re: So how much does this impact post war achievment? Sep 15, 17:28
Alex Hellmund 22% Sep 16, 06:11
Mike J re: Alex Hellmund Sep 20, 21:16
 gennady re: Its ridiculous. Sep 15, 18:28
Wen Jin WOW! The entire adult population was either killed or maimed! Sep 15, 19:19
 Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 19:47
Oleg Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 20:54
Max re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 21:58
Oleg re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 16, 04:31
 Max time to draw a bottom line (+) Sep 16, 15:06
  • Wen Jin Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 15:50
    Max re: Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 17:22
  •  Karl Brandel re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 03:04
    Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 07:53
    Wen Jin not to mention another 60 million maimed (-) Sep 18, 19:22
    Brad Sallows re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 00:07
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 05:06
     Samuel Don't forget Sep 18, 11:11
    Lee Dowd re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 15:57
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 18:15
    Henry Oster re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 09:48
    JP re: Leadership Failures -- Soviet war casualties Sep 21, 00:58
    Pat re: hidden holocaust again slav populations ? Sep 16, 22:44

    Threads navigation:  22 <<<  21  >>> 20

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1808, visitors today 1742, now 205