Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Max: time to draw a bottom line

Oleg, Krivosheev figures really look convincing, but the problem with them is not that they are too low, for all we know they MAY BE TOO HIGH... The problem with them is that they are unascertainable, that for 50 years Soviets had been feeding the world with numbers ranging from 6 to 30 million, and then all of the sudden some secret figures, with accuracy down to the last single man (can you believe this?) emerge. You must admit that to a reasonable man this appears a sort of weird, especially given the terrible losses of 1941 when whole divisions and armies simply disappeared from OB, while their commanders didn't know where their units were, let alone their casualty numbers. Anyway one way or another we should face the fact that victors paid a much higher price in terms of human lives than the beaten. Believe me I wish it had been the other way round, which does not mean that German casualties were small - they were immense. For a large European country, such as Germany, some 2mn KIA was something they could never recover from. We also shouldn't forget the immense casualties, especially in POW, suffered by German satellites. We should also include KIA among foreign volunteers and former Soviet citizens that fought on the German side.
It's hard to believe that these figures are real, but when we look at the immense casualties of the WW1, and then consider the fact that the Soviet tactics changed very little from those of WW1, we'll see they are entirely real. Sure, Russians had some very advanced theories but the reality was mostly wave after wave of suicidal attacks in the open terrain, sometimes even without artillery barrage or air support. Germans, however, after paying a huge price in WW1, adopted and effectively used some new tactics, such as of Assault teams for example, with which they successfully experimented in WW1. I also attribute the huge Soviet losses to the Stalin's "at all and regardless of any cost" tactics, and general Stalinist attitude to individual human life.
Soviets however were good learners, and as the war progressed they adopted more and more of German Blitzkrieg tactics, while Hitler, erroneously believing that Soviets were winning because their tactics were better, started to adopt former Soviet stupid "stand fast", "disregard flanks", etc. tactics. Also don't forget that most of the war Soviets were on the offensive and this means higher casualties.
Regards

16 September 2000, 15:06:36


21. Karl Brandel Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 09:05

 Arashekino re: So how much does this impact post war achievment? Sep 15, 17:28
Alex Hellmund 22% Sep 16, 06:11
Mike J re: Alex Hellmund Sep 20, 21:16
 gennady re: Its ridiculous. Sep 15, 18:28
Wen Jin WOW! The entire adult population was either killed or maimed! Sep 15, 19:19
 Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 19:47
Oleg Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 20:54
Max re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 21:58
Oleg re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 16, 04:31
  •  Max time to draw a bottom line Sep 16, 15:06
    Wen Jin Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 15:50
    Max re: Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 17:22
  •  Karl Brandel re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 03:04
    Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 07:53
    Wen Jin not to mention another 60 million maimed (-) Sep 18, 19:22
    Brad Sallows re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 00:07
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 05:06
     Samuel Don't forget Sep 18, 11:11
    Lee Dowd re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 15:57
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 18:15
    Henry Oster re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 09:48
    JP re: Leadership Failures -- Soviet war casualties Sep 21, 00:58
    Pat re: hidden holocaust again slav populations ? Sep 16, 22:44

    Threads navigation:  22 <<<  21  >>> 20

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1807, visitors today 1741, now 204