Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Henry Oster: re: Total Soviet war casualties

I am particularly interested in the failures of leadership which resulted in such huge casualties on both sides. I invite commentary on the following:
1) Invading the Soviet Union, with its challenges of terrain and distance was risky at best, yet the OKH became an optimistic participant during the planning stage.
2) Casualties of 275,000 for the border battles, and 200,000 for September, estimated by Reserve CinC Fromm, and quoted by Halder, proved to be reasonable estimates. However, these losses were never replaced, and supply and logistic failures, which were forseen but ignored, made quick victory impossible.
Even before the planning of Barbarossa, the General Staff had effectively relinquished its duties and prerogatives, basically submitting to Hitler's personal dictates. There was no German counterpart to the British Committee of the Chiefs of Staff, organized in 1922 in order to solve command conflicts. Open dissent, such as that between Admiral Raeder and Hitler was rare.
4) Passive dissent, such as resignation planned by Halder, and discouraged by Brauchitch, was apparently unusual. If carried out on a wide scale do you think it would have been effective?
(Despite the resulting prosecutions).

16 September 2000, 09:48:52


21. Karl Brandel Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 09:05

 Arashekino re: So how much does this impact post war achievment? Sep 15, 17:28
Alex Hellmund 22% Sep 16, 06:11
Mike J re: Alex Hellmund Sep 20, 21:16
 gennady re: Its ridiculous. Sep 15, 18:28
Wen Jin WOW! The entire adult population was either killed or maimed! Sep 15, 19:19
 Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 19:47
Oleg Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 20:54
Max re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 21:58
Oleg re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 16, 04:31
 Max time to draw a bottom line (+) Sep 16, 15:06
Wen Jin Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 15:50
Max re: Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 17:22
 Karl Brandel re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 03:04
Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 07:53
Wen Jin not to mention another 60 million maimed (-) Sep 18, 19:22
Brad Sallows re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 00:07
Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 05:06
 Samuel Don't forget Sep 18, 11:11
Lee Dowd re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 15:57
Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 18:15
  • Henry Oster re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 09:48
    JP re: Leadership Failures -- Soviet war casualties Sep 21, 00:58
  • Pat re: hidden holocaust again slav populations ? Sep 16, 22:44

    Threads navigation:  22 <<<  21  >>> 20

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1818, visitors today 1752, now 198