Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Brad Sallows: re: Total Soviet war casualties

This thread seems to generate some strong emotions. I have just a few observations.
First, however inaccurate it might be for each available year of data, counts of the Soviet population prior and after the GPW might help to place upper and lower limits on the likely total of lives lost in the SU during the GPW. I note also that 1930's collectivization would presumably have some impact. But based on a population and growth rate prior to 1941, one should be able to predict (roughly) what the population should have been on a subsequent year and compare that to actual figures.
Second, since there seems to be a common desire to establish correct figures and not make unfounded assumptions, perhaps any assumption that wounded were abandoned by their friends to die should be discarded unless there is much documented evidence to the contrary. If anything, the anecdotal accounts I read tend to emphasize that soldiers everywhere will bear additional risks, and perhaps abort the tactical mission, in order to evacuate their comrades. In practice, if wounded were abandoned I would think it would occur under controlled conditions (ie. on order), that some protective caregivers would remain with them, and they would eventually be documented as PoW rather than KIA.
I will hazard a guess that the reason this discussion continually resurfaces is to prove or disprove that one army was "better" than the other. For those who hold that objective in mind, I don't think "deaths" is a valid measure. Because if large number of wounded did in fact fall into enemy hands, then the "combat effectiveness" of the victor is skewed by the deaths of soldiers which would not have occurred if they had not had to wait for care, and then perhaps died only because the care could not or would not be given.
Also, I remember reading a suggestion that the Red Army losses of the summer of 1941 be excluded, due to the exceptionally chaotic situation facing the Red Army at the time. Perhaps the same argument can be made for the Germany Army in 1945.

16 September 2000, 00:07:04


21. Karl Brandel Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 09:05

 Arashekino re: So how much does this impact post war achievment? Sep 15, 17:28
Alex Hellmund 22% Sep 16, 06:11
Mike J re: Alex Hellmund Sep 20, 21:16
 gennady re: Its ridiculous. Sep 15, 18:28
Wen Jin WOW! The entire adult population was either killed or maimed! Sep 15, 19:19
 Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 19:47
Oleg Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 20:54
Max re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 21:58
Oleg re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 16, 04:31
 Max time to draw a bottom line (+) Sep 16, 15:06
Wen Jin Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 15:50
Max re: Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 17:22
 Karl Brandel re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 03:04
Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 07:53
Wen Jin not to mention another 60 million maimed (-) Sep 18, 19:22
  • Brad Sallows re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 00:07
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 05:06
     Samuel Don't forget Sep 18, 11:11
    Lee Dowd re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 15:57
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 18:15
    Henry Oster re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 09:48
    JP re: Leadership Failures -- Soviet war casualties Sep 21, 00:58
    Pat re: hidden holocaust again slav populations ? Sep 16, 22:44
  • Threads navigation:  22 <<<  21  >>> 20

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1813, visitors today 1747, now 209