Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Karl Brandel: Total Soviet war casualties

Dear all,
As there has an interesting side discussion on total Soviet war casualties in another thread below started, I would like to cover this topic in more depth. I believe I found also some weeks ago the following post on this site:
�A few years ago (1995) I heard a Massey Lecture by the eminent historian John Keegan. The topic of his lecture was just how wrong we can be about what we think we know. In particular, he observed that in general, estimates in Western histories of Soviet military and civilian casualties during the Second World War range from twenty to twenty-five million people killed. He observed that since the archives in the Lyubyanka have become available to scholars, it has emerged that as many as SIXTY MILLION SOVIET CITIZENS died between 1941 and 1945. The accepted estimates in Western histories are wrong, out by as much as 300%. If our guesses and assumptions can be that wrong about something so important, who knows what else we are wrong about? �
Obviously not only the estimates of the western historians were wrong but those of their Soviet/Russian colleagues, intentionally or not, also.
Any further comments to Soviet losses and casualties, civil and military, killed by the Axis and the Soviets, as well as due to starvation etc. would be highly welcomed,
kind regards
Karl Brandel

15 September 2000, 09:05:59


  • 21. Karl Brandel Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 09:05

     Arashekino re: So how much does this impact post war achievment? Sep 15, 17:28
    Alex Hellmund 22% Sep 16, 06:11
    Mike J re: Alex Hellmund Sep 20, 21:16
     gennady re: Its ridiculous. Sep 15, 18:28
    Wen Jin WOW! The entire adult population was either killed or maimed! Sep 15, 19:19
     Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 15, 19:47
    Oleg Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 20:54
    Max re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 15, 21:58
    Oleg re: Yazov quoted Krivosheyev Sep 16, 04:31
     Max time to draw a bottom line (+) Sep 16, 15:06
    Wen Jin Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 15:50
    Max re: Offensives don't mean higher casulaties Sep 16, 17:22
     Karl Brandel re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 03:04
    Max re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 07:53
    Wen Jin not to mention another 60 million maimed (-) Sep 18, 19:22
    Brad Sallows re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 00:07
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 05:06
     Samuel Don't forget Sep 18, 11:11
    Lee Dowd re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 15:57
    Oleg re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 18, 18:15
    Henry Oster re: Total Soviet war casualties Sep 16, 09:48
    JP re: Leadership Failures -- Soviet war casualties Sep 21, 00:58
    Pat re: hidden holocaust again slav populations ? Sep 16, 22:44

    Threads navigation:  22 <<<  21  >>> 20

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1797, visitors today 1731, now 215