Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Wen Jin: I have that book

Ok, I went looking, and it lists 15,000 KIA. But then Duffy is a strange case; he claims a 4:1 kill ratio for the Wehrmacht in 1944 (probably very unlikely, considering overall Soviet superiority to be ~1.5:1). He also claims that the USSR lost 30 million dead. 30 million + another 30-50 million maimed would easily cripple a country of 180 million, so I doubt that the USSR could suffer so heavily and still stay afloat. I think that the "30 million" has been repeated so often that it has become a sort of fact. Also, I've noticed that the book uses significantly more German accounts, including so many of those soldiers' stories of hordes, brutality, etc.

15 September 2000, 02:24:56


17.  Mathias Forsberg Soviet Oder-Weichsel offensive Sep 13, 13:12

Wen Jin First , spell my name correctly. Sep 13, 19:35
 Mathias Forsberg Sorry, my mistake Sep 14, 02:21
 Wen Jin Couldn't agree with you more Sep 14, 03:19
Oleg re: Sorry, my mistake Sep 14, 23:05
  • Wen Jin I have that book Sep 15, 02:24
  • Threads navigation:  18 <<<  17  >>> 16

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1867, visitors today 1801, now 165