Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Oleg: re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ...

"Civil War and Volga Famine (1918-1922): 3,000,000 - 5,000,000"
Why do you blame only the communists for the Civil War? What kind of ridiculous propaganda is that? If Mahno kills some White officers, is that also the commies' fault? Also, I haven't seen any conclusive proof yet (only unsubstaniated claims) that Volga famine was artificial.
"Political repressions in the 1920s: tens of thousands"
True
"Forced collectivization and 'dekulakization' (after 1929): 10,000,000-14,000,000"
Ridiculous - read V.N.Zemskov "The Kulak Exile in the 30s"
"Ukrainian terror famine (1932-1933): 6,000,000 - 7,000,000"
This is by far the highest number ever quoted. The mean seems to be at 3,000,000 and there are still arguments if the famine was artificial.
"Great Terror (1934-1939) and purges: 1,000,000"
Maybe, but seems a bit too high, considering the total number of executions during Stalin's reign was around 600,000 (Zemskov)
"Deportation to the Gulag (to 1937): 10,000,000"
I thought these statistics were about people killed? Or is that guy claiming all those people died? Read Zemskov, "GULAG (a historico-sociological aspect)"
"Shootings and random executions (1937-1939): 1,000,000"
What the hell is that? Completely ridiculous. Do you think some NKVD people would walk around randomly shooting people in the streets?
"Deportation from Eastern Poland, Baltic States and Rumania (1939-1940): 2,000,000"
And they all died? Yeah right!
"Foreign POWs: Poles, Finns, Germans, Rumanians, Japanese: 1,000,000"
True, and how is that a crime? The country was starving, many POWs were captured in a bad condition, and you (and Davies) claim they were killed on purpose?
"Deportation to the Gulag (1939-1945): 7,000,000"
False! Read Zemskov!
"Deportation of nationalities: Volga Germans, Chechens, Ingush, Crimean Tatars, etc.: 1,000,000"
Again, you and Davies claim they all died?
"Post-war screening of repatriates and inhabitants of ex-occupied territory: 5,000,000 - 6,000,000"
So they were screening them in such an evil way that they were dropping dead like flies. Are you sure these statistics are about *deaths*?
"Gross total (median estimate): circa 54 millions"
BS, MS, PHD
Sorry to burst your bubble, but communists did kill less people than Nazis (and that's considering they had more power and ruled far longer).

14 September 2000, 19:02:48


9.  Arashekino Life under Soviets? Sep 3, 18:51

Mirek Wawrzynski re: Life under Soviets? Ypu are joking or yoy never read Soviet history? Sep 4, 21:48
 Arashekino re: Life under Soviets? Ypu are joking or yoy never read Soviet history? Sep 4, 22:03
A Pole What famine?! Sep 8, 00:41
A Pole Example => Kosovo Sep 8, 00:46
Sergei K. re: Example => Kosovo Sep 8, 04:21
Mirek Wawrzynski re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 4, 21:58
 Arashekino re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 4, 22:17
Sergei Koptenko re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 5, 17:30
Lee Dowd re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 5, 21:17
 Sergei Koptenko Propaganda vc truth Sep 6, 02:27
Lee Dowd re: Propaganda vc truth Sep 6, 13:58
Stephen B re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 6, 01:57
 Denes Bernad re: Life in Communism Sep 6, 23:20
 Stephen re: Women in the Army? Sep 7, 03:06
 Arashekino re: Steve check out "Reality of War" on this site for another perspecitve. (-) Sep 7, 08:08
Men re: Life in Communism (+) Sep 7, 18:16
 Alex Wood re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 5, 22:05
 Stephen B re: Some very good points... Sep 6, 02:21
Wen Jin "The Gulag Archipelago" was written under Khruschev's administration Sep 5, 02:16
Wen Jin Oops, sorry (wrong Gulag book) Sep 5, 02:57
Oleg re: Life under Soviets? You are joking or you never read real Soviet history? Sep 5, 18:10
Oleg re: Life under Soviets? Sep 5, 23:03
BrianJ re: Life under WHICH Soviets? (+) Sep 7, 03:47
Oleg re: Life under WHICH Soviets? Sep 7, 21:47
B52 re: Life under WHICH Soviets? Sep 9, 11:16
Denes Bernad For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 13, 06:32
 Arashekino re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 13, 11:17
Lee Dowd re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 13, 15:56
 Arashekino re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 13, 17:12
Lee Dowd re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 13, 22:10
JWB re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 16, 08:16
Samuel re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 13, 20:51
  • Oleg re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 14, 19:02
     Samuel re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 15, 00:40
     Arashekino re: For the record: Categories and no. of people killed in ... Sep 15, 04:20
    Oleg Not as simple Sep 15, 21:02
     Men re: Not as simple Sep 15, 21:31
  •  Arashekino re: How did extreme loss in WW II impact ability to realize Communist dream? (-) Sep 13, 11:20
     Oleg Do you really think that the Soviet government wanted that? (-) Sep 15, 01:23

    Threads navigation:  10 <<<  9  >>> 8

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1997, visitors today 1931, now 80