| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
43,000 for the entire theatre of operations is very reasonable. Probably 5-10,000 of those occurred outside of the main axis. But casualties do not tell the whole story. Whenever I compare casualties, I only compare KIAs, since less than a quarter of all wounded suffer serious wounds. Since the German Army was retreating at a rate of 30-50 km per day, the great majority of the casualties would be KIA and POW. Many of the wounded would also be counted as POWs, and many others would be left to bleed to death. So even though the casualty ratio may be 2:1 or so, the death ratio could be as high as 4:1. Of about 500,000 German casualties, I wouldn't be surprised if at least 150,000 of them were KIA and DOW.
The Red Army had 584,778 total casualties in East Prussia, but they probably acheived a favorable kill ratio because most of the Germans were either killed or captured. In my opinion, death rates are best in comparing two armies because most of the wounded fully recover.
14 September 2000, 03:19:18
17.
Mathias Forsberg
Soviet Oder-Weichsel offensive Sep 13, 13:12
Wen Jin
First , spell my name correctly. Sep 13, 19:35
Mathias Forsberg
Sorry, my mistake Sep 14, 02:21
Wen Jin
Couldn't agree with you more Sep 14, 03:19
Oleg
re: Sorry, my mistake Sep 14, 23:05
Wen Jin
I have that book Sep 15, 02:24
Threads navigation: 18 <<< 17 >>> 16
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1865, visitors today 1799, now 168 |