Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Mathias Forsberg: Sorry, my mistake

OK, then it makes more sense. I can't really comment your figures but Glantz bases most of his figures on archival records. The problem with Glantz' figures is that it doesn't specify which units are included (only the timeline). However the soviet casualty estimate for the germans exceeds 660.000 men and about 1300 tanks & assault guns. This seem to include the combat up to march 1945 though. Then soviet casualties rises dramatically:
Vistula-Oder offensive (Jan 12-Feb 3): 194,191 (43,476 KIA)
East Prussian offensive (Jan 13-April 25): 584,778 (126,464 KIA)
Lower Silesian Offensive (Feb 8-24): 99,386 (23,557 KIA)
East Pomerania Offensive (Feb 10-April 4): 234,360 (55,315 KIA)
Upper Silesian Offensive (March 15-31): 66,801 (15,876 KIA)
If these figures comes from situation reports I see no reason not to trust them. These figures includes larger areas and timeline than the Oder-Wistula operations but KIA figures are a bit over 20,000 at least.
But the Red Army probably achieved a 2:1 casualty ratio at least (including POWs).
/Mathias
P.S the numbers are from When Titans Clashed, appendix B (personell and material losses)

14 September 2000, 02:21:47


17.  Mathias Forsberg Soviet Oder-Weichsel offensive Sep 13, 13:12

Wen Jin First , spell my name correctly. Sep 13, 19:35
  •  Mathias Forsberg Sorry, my mistake Sep 14, 02:21
     Wen Jin Couldn't agree with you more Sep 14, 03:19
    Oleg re: Sorry, my mistake Sep 14, 23:05
    Wen Jin I have that book Sep 15, 02:24
  • Threads navigation:  18 <<<  17  >>> 16

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1864, visitors today 1798, now 167