Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Max: re: Total German losses in WW2

Unfortunately this "careful research done by post war scholars" was heavily influenced by prevailing political situation and orders from above. Right after the war Stalin declared that Russians lost just over 6 million. When Khrustchev kicked Stalin out of the Mausoleum he said that Russians lost 20 million. Breshnev and the party thought that Stalin wasn't that bad after all and that 20 million was perhaps too much. When Perestroika came, Gorbatchev said that Stalin and Brezhnev were fools and that losses were some 27 million. Some crazy Russian perestroika researches went as far as to say the USSR lost over 50 million. I'm just asking myself where the hell the truth is. Krivosheev is just one of the researches, albeit widely used in the West. But I guess earlier in the forum some Russian guy gave the name of another Russian researcher who in his article rebuts Krivosheev, and crazily asserts that the ratio was some 15 to 1 in German favor. No doubt Nazis were bad liars and Goebels was a great manipulator, but Germans kept their books and their statistics are based on firm casualty figures that had arrived directly from troops and after the war were repeatedly checked and rechecked by various independent German and Western scholars, most of whom were no Nazi sympathizers.
Regards

13 September 2000, 12:15:07


15. Oleg Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 21:43

 Wen Jin re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 22:50
Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 23:06
Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 09:59
 Arashekino re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 11:03
  •  Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 12:15
    Lee Dowd re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 21:58
     Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 13:03
  • Oleg Thanks for the figures Sep 14, 18:14
     Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 14, 18:27
     Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 14, 19:21
    Max addendum Sep 14, 19:30
    Oleg re: addendum Sep 14, 23:30
    Max re: addendum Sep 15, 09:49
    Oleg Are you serious?!!! Sep 15, 20:38
    Wen Jin re: addendum Sep 15, 02:36
    Max re: addendum Sep 15, 09:57
    Wen Jin Ridiculous Sep 15, 19:24
    Pat re: 700000 women in German military !! Sep 18, 22:42
    Frank DeLaglio re: Total German losses in WW2 (+) Sep 16, 00:25
    Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 18, 18:46
     Mathias Forsberg Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 19, 02:42
    Oleg re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 19, 18:54
     Lee Dowd re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 19, 19:45
    David Woolbright re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 21, 08:20
    Mike Johnson re: Only 5,3 million in Heer Sep 22, 16:37
    Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 19, 09:01
    Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 19, 19:07
     Mathias Forsberg Krivosheev's number too high? Sep 20, 03:49
    Oleg Here's complete Krivosheyev's data Sep 20, 18:39
    Mike Johnson re: Here's complete Krivosheyev's data Sep 22, 16:46
    Max re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 20, 13:21
    Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 12, 22:54
    Oleg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 00:28
    Wen Jin re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 03:11
     Arashekino re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 04:31
     Mathias Forsberg re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 12:51
     Arashekino re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 15, 17:19
    Wen Jin re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 15, 19:36
     Mathias Forsberg Let me create my own theories, please... (+) Sep 16, 16:27
     Arashekino re: Let me create my own theories, please... Sep 16, 17:01
     Mathias Forsberg Documents, KIA and Bagration Sep 16, 18:05
    Denes Bernad re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 13, 06:46
     Oleg Thank you Sep 14, 18:16
     Frank DeLaglio re: Total German losses in WW2 Sep 14, 21:37
     Frank DeLaglio New Try Sep 14, 21:47
    Oleg re: New Try Sep 14, 23:37
     Arashekino re: New Try Sep 15, 04:11
     Mathias Forsberg Archival dates Sep 15, 12:50
     Max re: New Try Sep 15, 09:33
    Wen Jin So you're saying that everything Soviet is a lie? (-) Sep 15, 19:26
    Max re: So you're saying that everything Soviet is a lie? Sep 15, 19:50
    Oleg Who is that researcher? Sep 15, 20:44
    Max re: Who is that researcher? Sep 15, 21:50
    Oleg re: Who is that researcher? Sep 16, 04:53
     Denes Bernad re: New German book on total German losses in WW2 Sep 19, 00:04
    brianb why is it so hard to believe Sep 19, 22:30

    Threads navigation:  16 <<<  15  >>> 14

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1878, visitors today 1812, now 157