Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mike Johnson: re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III

Yes, they bought the tanks, but I wondered why Germany would sell its main battle tank of the day, especially when they did not have enough for their own forces. I first thought it was an intelligence coup, but as a small item on a large list in an economic treaty, it makes more sense.
As for Kulik cooking the data, I found that unlikely (especially when you could get shot for doing so). That is why I looked for another answer. I know from my own professional experience that groups of people, with the same goal in mind, can and occasionally do manipulate data to support their cause.
What do you think of the idea that Germany actually sold a tank that they had withdrawn from use (and was very different from the rest of the PzKw II line and had a suspension similar to the T-34 and BT-7 it was compared with), instead of their main battle tank of the day? It seems to fit the data you present quite well. As far as I can find, it appears to be the only German tank that potentially could reach 70 KPH and it was being compared with wheeled speeds of the T-34 and BT-7. I was wondering what additional information you might have that could support or preclude this possibility.

8 September 2000, 16:00:39


11. Mike Johnson Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III (+) Sep 8, 04:09

 Valera Potapov re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 10:38
  • Mike Johnson re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 16:00
     Arashekino re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 19:28
     Mike Johnson re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 9, 02:11
     Valera Potapov Pz-III 37-mm gun Sep 9, 11:22
     Arashekino re: Qualitative differences beats gun/armour power? Sep 16, 17:05
     David Woolbright re: Qualitative differences beats gun/armour power? Sep 17, 05:36
  • Threads navigation:  12 <<<  11  >>> 10

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1955, visitors today 1889, now 50