Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mike Johnson: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III

I was puzzled some time ago while reading in the Russian Military Zone discussion of the development of the T-34 at history.vif2.ru/t34_76_2.html where it discussed comparisons of the T-34 (and the BT-7) with two German T-IIIs in the Summer of 1940.
First question: how did the Soviet Military get the tanks? I think I have found the answer: In the economic agreement signed 11 February 1940, an exchange worth 650 Million Marks was agreed to whereby Soviets supplied Germany with raw materials, including food and oil and Germany supplied the Soviet Union equipment for producing energy and a list of military equipment including some PzKw IIIs.
Second questions: most of the comparison did not surprise me. T-34 superior in firepower and protection; T-III quieter and with better communication, turret layout, optics gear, engine, and suspension. However, it is the speed that surprised me. The PzKw IIIA had a design speed of 32KPH and later models had maximum design speeds of 40 KPH. Yet the Soviet engineers were surprised to find speeds of "69.7 km/h whereas the T-34's best result was 48.2 km/h. The BT-7, which was used as a standard model, could run on wheels at only 68.1 km/h." I too was surprised. What was this tank then that could go almost 70KPH?
One thought is that Kulik (or a subordinate) cooked the data so that he could have evidence in his attempt to kill the T-34. But another possibility is that Hitler substituted another tank. The PzKw III completed its first production run (model E) in 1939 and the second (F) in July 1940. The third production run (G) started in April 1940. These were the German main battle tanks at the time. But he did have a substitute that might be reasonably passed off as a Panzer III. The PzKw II C was the first production r un of the II, which was followed by the F. The PzKw IID and E had a completely different suspension, referred to as a torsion bar suspenion. This suspension had 4 large road wheels and could operate as tracked or wheeled. After 250 tanks the line was stopped in early 1940 because of poor off road capability. Tracked they had a road speed of 55 KPH and I have not found a speed on wheels. This suspension seems to have been a German attempt to copy the suspension of the BT (and later T-34) line and the UK cruiser line which were both based on Christie suspension. Poland also built prototypes with this suspension (the 10TP). Soviet engineers compared the T-III with their own wheel-tracked tanks. Therefore, could the PzKw IID/E be the mysterious T-III compared at Kubinka?
I would appreciate any information anybody might have concerning these tests or thoughts on the possibility of my suggestion.
As this episode caused the suspension of T-34 production and took the personal intervention of Voroshilov to get the production back on track how long was production delayed. Given that production in the summer of 1941 was a couple of hundred a month, I wonder if this caused hundreds of T-34s to be unavailable that summer that might otherwise have been or if Voroshilov had not acted if there would have been a T-34 for the Germans to encounter. Finally, was it common for former MOD Voroshilov to personally intervene in such decisions from his position on the Politburo?

8 September 2000, 04:09:42


  • 11. Mike Johnson Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 04:09

     Valera Potapov re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 10:38
    Mike Johnson re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 16:00
     Arashekino re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 8, 19:28
     Mike Johnson re: Comparison of T-34 with PzKw III Sep 9, 02:11
     Valera Potapov Pz-III 37-mm gun Sep 9, 11:22
     Arashekino re: Qualitative differences beats gun/armour power? Sep 16, 17:05
     David Woolbright re: Qualitative differences beats gun/armour power? Sep 17, 05:36

    Threads navigation:  12 <<<  11  >>> 10

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1953, visitors today 1887, now 48