Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Jari Lievonen: re: A small note

Hi,
There is a relatively new book on Kursk (name of the author unfortunately eludes my mind) called simply "Kursk". It gives an excellent account of the battle and breaks many myths. Battle of Kursk has in a way grown out of proportion because both sides had a good reason for that. Initially the Germans declared that they are going to take back the initiative. When they failed and lost it was tempting to say that it was all resolved at Kursk and we lost because ..... -but we could have one if, if and if. Likewise, for the Russians Kursk was definitely a strategic victory (even if they had lost all the equipment stated in the previous messages) which they had to use in their propaganda. Because the war was big there had to be a desicive battle, right? War of attrition, which it actually was, is not sexy. Later on the myths lived (and will live) on because they are sexy.
Regards,
Jari
PS. The above does by no mean doubt that Kursk was still the biggest land battle in WWII.
PS2. The most interesting detail in the book is the battle of Prokhorovka where, as the author claims, the Russian commander of the 5th Guards Tank Army actually lost his nerve at the crucial moment. He was holding a good defensive position in and around Prokhorovka. SS Leibstandarte was preparing an attack and had spread it's tanks in broad line. At this moment Rotmistrov then decides to attack with all his forces across an open field. The result was appalling from the Russian point of view as can be expected when Germans could use their long range cannons to their advantage. The author put the losses to almost 400. However, this figure was discussed on this board some months ago and I belive the consensus was that Russian losses were around 200, 250 max. In the book it is also stated that out of the 400 only some 30% were total write offs. And it has to be remebered that not all tansk were T-34's or alike but there were also a number of light tanks.

7 September 2000, 10:32:12

7.  Easycola About snipers then, reliability of data... Aug 31, 21:47

Oleg re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Aug 31, 22:20
 Easycola re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Aug 31, 22:48
Oleg re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Aug 31, 23:01
 Easycola re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Aug 31, 23:24
 Lev re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Sep 1, 04:50
Jari Lievonen re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Sep 1, 12:14
Wen Jin re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Sep 1, 19:36
 Jorge Visca re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Sep 2, 02:24
Tapani Kossila re: About snipers then, reliability of data... Sep 5, 14:24
 Arashekino re: Still not complete! Sep 3, 02:59
 Easycola re: Still not complete! Sep 4, 16:54
Wen Jin About the casualties Sep 2, 22:49
 Arashekino re: About the casualties Sep 3, 03:09
Wen Jin re: About the casualties Sep 3, 03:16
Oleg re: About the casualties Sep 5, 18:02
 Max re: About the casualties Sep 5, 18:39
Sergei Koptenko hearsay and statistics Sep 5, 19:04
Wen Jin Casualties and myths Sep 5, 19:37
Mathias Forsberg Casualites at Kursk Sep 6, 01:35
Wen Jin Why your numbers are ridiculous Sep 6, 02:46
 Frank DeLaglio re: Why your numbers are ridiculous Sep 6, 03:38
Wen Jin Ridiculous Sep 6, 03:43
Mathias Forsberg Then what is the "truth"? Sep 6, 03:57
 Sergei K. Because they right Sep 6, 04:14
Wen Jin If he was very pro-German... Sep 6, 04:21
 Mathias Forsberg re: If he was very pro-German... Sep 6, 10:45
 Stephen re: Erikson Sep 7, 03:21
Sergei K. re: Albert Seaton and David Glantz Sep 7, 04:49
 Mathias Forsberg Tank losses Sep 6, 03:53
Wen Jin You want German Documents?? It won't be pretty... Sep 6, 04:06
Jari Lievonen Availability figures do not indicate losses accuartely Sep 6, 11:59
Mathias Forsberg re: You want German Documents?? It won't be pretty... Sep 6, 15:42
 Juha re: Why your numbers are ridiculous Sep 6, 10:51
Philip Van Acker re: Why your numbers are ridiculous Sep 7, 18:15
Oleg Wrong! Sep 7, 21:36
Wen Jin re: Wrong! Sep 8, 05:38
 Sergei K. re: Casualites at Kursk Sep 6, 03:35
Wen Jin Where are these people coming from?? Sep 6, 04:00
Mathias Forsberg re: Where are these people coming from?? Sep 6, 04:06
Sergei K. re: Where are these people coming from?? Sep 6, 05:33
 Wen Jin One thing, Sergei Sep 6, 06:04
Wen Jin A small note Sep 6, 09:00
Mathias Forsberg re: A small note Sep 6, 15:37
Wen Jin re: A small note Sep 6, 16:32
Mathias Forsberg Red Army officers know better then myself Sep 6, 18:36
Wen Jin Yes, but I don't see how 1200 write-offs make sense Sep 6, 19:34
Mathias Forsberg re: Yes, but I don't see how 1200 write-offs make sense Sep 6, 20:13
Oleg Another possible explanation Sep 6, 20:39
 Wen Jin Tank Prices Sep 6, 21:52
Mathias Forsberg re: Another possible explanation Sep 7, 13:55
 Men re: Yes, but I don't see how 1200 write-offs make sense Sep 6, 21:23
 Arashekino re: I agree with Men, answer Mathia? (-) Sep 7, 01:08
Mathias Forsberg OK, my theory (+) Sep 7, 13:49
  • Jari Lievonen re: A small note Sep 7, 10:32
    Jari Lievonen Russian repair teams Sep 6, 12:08
    Mathias Forsberg re: Where are these people coming from?? Sep 6, 15:46
     Arashekino re: Where are these people coming from?? Sep 6, 08:01
    Wen Jin The Germans didn't care about casualties Sep 6, 08:18
    Jari Lievonen Why Citadelle was called off Sep 6, 12:16
     Max Cost of human life Sep 6, 12:51
     Wen Jin re: Cost of human life Sep 6, 16:34
    Sergei K. re: Cost of human life (+) Sep 12, 17:20
  • Oleg re: About the casualties Sep 5, 22:44
    Wen Jin I suspect Sep 6, 04:54
    Sergei Koptenko re: About the casualties Sep 5, 18:45
    Max re: About the casualties Sep 5, 20:00
    Sergei Koptenko Statistic vc. memoirs Sep 6, 01:53
    Wen Jin Exactly Sep 6, 02:49
    Lee Dowd re: Exactly Sep 6, 14:35
     Bogdanov re: About the casualties (+) Sep 8, 21:21
    Lee Dowd re: About the casualties Sep 8, 23:17
     Arashekino re: About the casualties Sep 9, 04:10
     Wen Jin re: About the casualties Sep 9, 06:31
    Lee Dowd casualty rates Sep 13, 16:11
     David Woolbright re: About the casualties Sep 17, 05:19
     Max re: About the casualties Sep 9, 12:41
    Sergei K. Cost of life (+) Sep 12, 17:11
     Wen Jin re: Cost of life Sep 12, 22:44
    Wen Jin That's 9/24-10/3/43---Stupid mental lapse on my part Sep 12, 23:19
     Arashekino re: Since when were Nazis part of Democratic world? (-) Sep 13, 11:22
    Bogdanov re: About the casualties Sep 15, 19:06

    Threads navigation:  8 <<<  7  >>> 6

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1321, visitors today 1255, now 146