Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Charles C Sharp: re: Czarist Russia- The greatest Power in History???

Historical Fantasy or "Might have been" arguments can be fun, and some people have made lucrative writing careers in the subject (L. Sprague DeCamp, Harry Turtledove, for instance) but unless you're debating complete fantasy, some historical trends have to be included. To conclude that "Czarist Russia" might become or remain a great or the greatest power, is to first assume it would remain Czarist Russia. Every country which has modernized or industrialized has gone through major political and social upheaval in the process. In addition, every industrialized country in Europe (and the USA) that went through WWI also went through a post-war brush with either socialism or fascism while trying to cope with the financial/social crises brought on by that war. Forget for a moment the entire Russian Revolution (which started before Lenin even got back into Russia - let's make the rash assumption that the trends starting under the Romanovs were somehow reversed before 1917!). How does Russia get through the post-war social, financial, and political upheavals of the 1920s and 1930s? Germany, Italy, Hungary, and Spain went Fascist. Britain, France, and the USA went or flirted with socialism (go ahead, define Roosevelt's New Deal without reference to socialism). By the 1950s, partly due to another war and partly to trends that started when the new century did, both the French and British overseas empires were largely gone.
Given all that, and the utter lack of any historical evidence for political adroitness or acuity on the part of the Romanov Dynasty since Alexander I, what are the chances of a "Czarist Russian Empire" surviving as such to the present day? Not good. Now, expanding the question to include, say, a Constitutional (Duma-Monarchy based) Russia becoming a late-20th century power might make a better argument. Remember though, Monarchy has been defined as "Government by Chance" and the genetic chances among the Romanovs weren't good...

4 September 2000, 03:42:17


8. Wen Jin Can you believe this? (+) Sep 3, 09:11

 Arashekino re: He could be right and you and I fools! (-) Sep 3, 18:52
Wen Jin Czarist Russia- The greatest Power in History??? Sep 3, 18:55
Henrik Krog re: Czarist Russia- The greatest Power in History??? Sep 4, 02:09
  • Charles C Sharp re: Czarist Russia- The greatest Power in History??? Sep 4, 03:42
    Wen Jin That was what I was thinking Sep 4, 04:36
     Arashekino re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan (-) Sep 5, 00:20
     Men re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan Sep 5, 17:32
    Sergei Koptenko re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan Sep 5, 18:05
    Men re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan Sep 5, 23:55
    Lee Dowd re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Sep 6, 14:03
     Stephen B re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan Sep 6, 02:04
    Sergei K. re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan Sep 6, 03:31
    Lee Dowd re: If Czar so good Why sell Alaska? Why lose to Japan Sep 6, 14:12
     Stephen re: Rocket scientists Sep 7, 03:12
    Sergei K. re: Rocket scientists Sep 8, 06:18
    Lenin What Soviet records?! Sep 8, 00:54
     Men re: What Soviet records?! Sep 8, 18:45
    gennady re: The loses of Civil war Sep 9, 16:34
  • Threads navigation:  9 <<<  8  >>> 7

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 2008, visitors today 1942, now 89