Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Carl-Fredrik Geust: re: about score of Finnish and Soviet fighters

Gennadi,
I am afraid you misunderstood me concerning the Morane-Spitfire misidentification at Turku (SW Finland) in Feb-March 1940. What I wanted to say that Soviet reports of sightings of "Spits" coincides with actual appearance of Moranes, but not a single Morane was lost here!
During the Winter War only two Moranes were shot down, both in SE Finland:
- 9.3.1940 MS-322 was hit by AA, caught fire and made a forced landing at Vilalahtio. Lt. Lupari was injured.
- 11.3.1940 MS-304 was hit by MG-fire from DB-3 gunners (two DB-3s of 7 DBAP were shot down), Ens. Inehmo made forced landing at Ruuhij�rvi. This a/c was repaired, and operationable 28.7.1941.
Concerning the "falseness" of VVS losses in the Winter War I have a different opinion. The Finnish Air Force claimed 190 aircraft shot down in the Winter War , and the Finnish anti-aircraft artillery 300 (note that practically all air fighting was taking place over Finnish territory, and thus almost all wrecks were consequently located, in addition a big number of aircraft were seen returning east- or southwards in flames and smoke. A big number of these wrecks were subsequently located summer 1941).
Furthermore I have personally worked extensively in RGVA (Moscow) and RGAVMF (St.Petersburg) with war diaries (ZhBD), opersvodki and loss reports of practically all Soviet aviation regiments involved.
My current estimation is that total losses of the Soviet Air Forces involved in the winter war (including VVS 7 A, VVS 13 A, VVS 8 A, VVS 15 A, VVS 9 A, VVS 14 A, VVS KBF, VVS SF, AON-1 and AON-2) amount to at least 650-700 aircraft (this sum includes naturally a big number of "non-combat" losses, however directly related to the war; in particular numerous losses of orientation during transfer flights in East Karelia, mid-air and ground collisions at air fields of LVO etc). I have recorded regiment numbers, crew lists and even individual aircraft c/n for most of these cases.
Please see Rodina no 12/1995 and Aviatsija i Kosmonavtika no 12/1997 for summaries of my research.
Concerning wartime confirmation of Finnish claims, primarily location of the wreck by ground forces, or secondarily witness by other pilots were required. Air combat reports were submitted to the reg.C.O. and further to AF HQ, where final acceptance and allocation of air victories to individual pilots (or collectively to the regiment, if individual pilot could not be identified) was made. The AF HQ very often refused acceptance of claims, if presented proof was not considered sufficent. (I will try to present more formal description of the Finnish air victory acceptance system later).
As indicated above, concerning the Winter War the claims are rather accurate, likewise for the advance into East carelia summer 1941 and also the retreat summer 1944. The real problems concern the air fighting over the Gulf of Finland in 1942-1943 where no wrecks could be located, and as you yourself indicate obviously the claims of both sides are exaggerated.
regards
Carl

1 September 2000, 22:49:10

2.  Clint Muse Soviet Lightnings Aug 28, 20:01

 Stephen B re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 29, 03:18
Tero Mistaken ID ? Aug 29, 08:10
gennady re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 29, 15:03
 Clint Muse re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 29, 16:10
 Juha re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 12:04
Scott Fraser re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 13:33
Jari Lievonen re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 15:17
Pentti Perttula re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 15:39
 gennady re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 31, 15:46
 gennady re: Soviet FW-189s Aug 31, 17:25
Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Soviet FW-189s, Lightnings etc (+) Sep 1, 00:53
Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Soviet Lightnings Sep 1, 00:57
gennady re: about score of Finnish and Soviet fighters (+) Sep 1, 18:31
  • Carl-Fredrik Geust re: about score of Finnish and Soviet fighters Sep 1, 22:49
  •  Mirek Wawrzynski re: Soviet Lightnings, maybe it is true Sep 3, 16:09
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Soviet Lightnings, maybe it is true Sep 3, 16:25
    Krzysztof Pawlowski re: Soviet Lightnings, maybe it is true Sep 4, 21:11
     Clint Muse re: Lockheed P-322 Sep 5, 01:43

    Threads navigation:  3 <<<  2  >>> 1

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1449, visitors today 1383, now 90