Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Jari Lievonen: Oleg, think you missed the point

Hi Oleg,
I think that you missed the point I was trying to make. What I tried to show was that there was not such a big difference between the Russian soldier of WWI and WWII as such. I chose the examples in order to say that Russian soldiers of WW I were not originally unmotivated contrary to what was initially claimed in this thread. Similarily, Russian soldier in the beginning of WW II was not necessarily the well motivated defender of the fatherland that could be induced from the initial question. In essence he was the same with more or less the same strengths and weaknesses on individual level.
If you claim that low morale had nothing to do with the mass surrenders I think you are wrong. A soldier who has low morale and does not believe in his cause is more prone of getting encircled and remain passive than a motivated soldier. He will also quit fighting much easier in "hopeless" situation. And bad leadership just multiplies the effect.
>Show me any other army that wouldn't surrender >in the situation RKKA found itself in 1941. In >fact, show me any other army that would keep on >fighting after the casualties taken in initial >battles.
Any army that has the space and resources would have kept fighting in the same situation as the Red Army. Given how the Germans behaved there was not much of a choice, was there?
Regards,
Jari

1 September 2000, 10:47:11

4.  James Quinn Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 17:26

Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 17:57
 James Quinn re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 21:26
 MODERATOR Attention to "Men" Aug 30, 22:21
Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 18:49
 Wen Jin That about sums it up (-) Aug 30, 19:24
 Nick re: A WAR OF OPPOSING IDEOLOGIES Aug 30, 21:26
 Jorge Visca Disagree. Aug 30, 21:32
 James Quinn re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 21:29
Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 21:41
 Jorge Visca re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 22:22
Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 22:48
 Stephen B re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 02:58
 Mr. L. L. re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 04:20
 Max re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 15:55
 Stephen B re: More to the story.... Sep 4, 20:02
 Arashekino re: More to the story.... Sep 4, 21:56
 Max re: More to the story.... Sep 5, 10:02
 Stephen B re: More to the story.... Sep 6, 02:17
Max re: More to the story.... Sep 6, 10:32
Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 17:34
Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 23:54
Jari Lievonen re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 12:31
Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 19:46
  • Jari Lievonen Oleg, think you missed the point Sep 1, 10:47
    Oleg You might be right, but... Sep 1, 22:48
  • Henry Oster re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 8, 09:38
     Alejandro Parra re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 2, 05:30
     Stephen B re: I will argue differnt times but basically... (+) Sep 4, 20:33
    Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 01:53
    David Woolbright re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 07:58
     Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 19:37
    Max re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 20:46
    Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 22:50
     David Woolbright re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 04:19
    Oleg Operation Bagration is... Sep 1, 22:41
     David Woolbright re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 08:05
     James Quinn Possible answer to this question Aug 31, 21:36
     Men re: Possible answer to this question Aug 31, 22:59
    Mike Johnson re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 22:57
     Oleg Agree 100% Aug 31, 23:09
     Stepan Mikhalik re: Agree 100% (+) Sep 1, 04:59
     Barry Morrison re: Agree 100% Sep 2, 11:11
    Bogdanov WHAT ABOUT THE 1812 and Napoleon? (-) Sep 22, 20:55
     Lev re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 04:54
     Mr. L. L. re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 05:48
     Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 15:06
    Mike Johnson re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 18:48
     Mr. L. L. re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 2, 20:35
    Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 3, 00:44
     Sergei koptenko Reading from the same book Sep 4, 01:01
    Oleg Minor comment about the number of tanks Sep 5, 22:52
    Mike Johnson re: Minor comment about the number of tanks (+) Sep 6, 16:31
    Sergei K. re: Minor comment about the number of tanks Sep 7, 05:17
     Mike Johnson re: Minor comment about the number of tanks Sep 8, 00:01
    Anatoly re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 08:46
     Stepan Mikhalik Similarities Sep 1, 09:36
    Arashekino re: Cliches abound! Sep 1, 17:04
     Arashekino re: Cliches abound! Sep 1, 17:31
    Mike Johnson re: Cliches abound! Sep 1, 19:04
     David Woolbright re: Cliches abound! Sep 2, 01:53
     Stepan Mikhalik Wrong Wrong Wrong (+) Sep 2, 14:01
     Stepan Mikhalik re: Wrong Wrong Wrong Sep 2, 14:03
     Arashekino re: Wrong Wrong Wrong Sep 3, 02:54
     Stepan Mikhalik re: Wrong Wrong Wrong (+) Sep 3, 05:49
    Scott Fraser Well said! Everyone should read this! n/t (-) Sep 3, 06:36
     Arashekino re: right right right (+) Sep 3, 18:33
     Mark Jaremco Western and Eastern Ukrainians (+) Sep 4, 00:03
    Scott Fraser Babi Yar � A. Anatoly (Kuznetsov) (+) Sep 4, 01:07
    Mr. L. L. Babi Yar � A. Anatoly Fiction Sep 4, 21:53
    Scott Fraser re: Babi Yar � A. Anatoly Fiction Sep 4, 23:30
     Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 22:55
    Anatoly re: for Oleg Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 08:56
     Dan re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 22:45

    Threads navigation:  5 <<<  4  >>> 3

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1379, visitors today 1313, now 101