Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


  Stepan Mikhalik: re: Agree 100%

Mike and Oleg are quite right! The Russian Army of 1914-17 was not at all like it is portrayed in most histories. This is do to both communist propaganda AND RESENTMENT in France and England about the Russians "not fulfilling their obligations" (surrendering).
As to the original question....
Comparing the Russian people of WW1 with those of WW2 is akin to (pardon the cliche) comparing apples and oranges. Why were the Russians of the 40's more zealous in defence of the Motherland?
The main differences-
1.Nazi Brutality
a. word of executions (Zoya et al) AND
impending slavery
Nazi racial policy emphasized the inferiority and worthlessness of the population. Thanks to an large propaganda dept., the public was well aware of the atrocities being committed under the said policy. Surrender meant not only the destruction of the state but also of homes, possesions and most importantly, ..families. Unlike WW1 surrender (for both man and country) meant almost certain doom.
The Germans of WW1 still had some concept of "Victorian Civility". Being a gentleman still had some signifigance.
2.Industrialization (which hasn't been discussed in depth)
a.higher literacy rates directly
increased effectiveness of propaganda in
WW2. The more literate and industrialized masses knew who and what they were fighting for. (In WW1 the peasant population made up an overwhelming majority of the population. The peasant with his land cared little for who or what was in charge as long as he got his neccessities and wasn't bothered with. He had no cares as to news or politics. Even nationality was often of little concern to the uneducated peasant! Whether under German rule or Tsarist rule, he would obey without question as long as his life remained stable..>>>I have quotes to support this view if requested>>>)
b.now that more of the population was in the factories rather than fields, war and occupation meant that there would be an iminent, large and negative change of life for workers and families.
If factories were shut down , the family would not eat. It was quite simple.
3.Stalinist Terror and Coercion
a. If you surrender to Nazis and were "liberated" by Red Army, you went to prison camps,... or worse. If you show signs of cowardice at the front, you were usually executed by the NKVD.
4.The Country was attacked in WW2 rather than acting an invading army in WW1.
a. Defending your homeland is hardly ever an "unpopular war". Many Russians in the intelligentsia and later throughout the nation expressed their displeasure with Russia's "foray into Europe".
5. The survival of the nation was not really at stake in WW1.
Until the complete disintigration of the Russian Government (and importantly, the army)in 1917, Russia was never in any real danger as to its existence. Although the Germans could have advanced as far as Moscow in late '17, they were never truly "at the gates".
6. The presence of Communist agitators at the front and behind the lines.
It was not the German army but actually German and Austrian funded communist agitators who wreaked the most
havoc on the Russian army in WW1. The Russian Army was holding back a large number of divisions, standing its ground as late as 1916.
The history books turn a blind and biased eye towards the heroic battles and victories that were won by the Russian Army between Tannenburg and the Revoplution. Many and indeed most Russian
troops showed valour and courage that was very often praised by the French and British.
....But foreign and non-slavic agitators funded by Germany wreaked havoc among the Russian front line soldiers. They spread lies among the many thousands of illiterate peasants about what was going on at home as well as military matters on the front. As the lies were repeated and losses mounted, the homesick , but brave peasant soldiers began to beleive them. (often for lack of other info)The Okhrana , unlike the later NKVD , was just not equipped to fight an indiginous propaganda war.The ensuing discord turned one of the most powerful armies in the world into a bickering and disjointed force that ended up having soldiers vote on matters that ranged between commissioning of officers and following of orders. With no structure and visions of fellow soldiers smoking cigarettes with Germans, mass dessertions of epic became the rule. Incidentally though, the Russian army had ceased to exist long before this occurred.
.....a long way to say "apples and oranges" , really.
As for some historians, it might do them well to listen to Oleg and others of his ilk. Russia was not the dying nation of communist propaganda in 1914. Nothing could be further from the truth. Russia was betrayed, ...and it has yet to recover

1 September 2000, 04:59:25

4.  James Quinn Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 17:26

Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 17:57
 James Quinn re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 21:26
 MODERATOR Attention to "Men" Aug 30, 22:21
Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 18:49
 Wen Jin That about sums it up (-) Aug 30, 19:24
 Nick re: A WAR OF OPPOSING IDEOLOGIES Aug 30, 21:26
 Jorge Visca Disagree. Aug 30, 21:32
 James Quinn re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 21:29
Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 21:41
 Jorge Visca re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 22:22
Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 22:48
 Stephen B re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 02:58
 Mr. L. L. re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 04:20
 Max re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 15:55
 Stephen B re: More to the story.... Sep 4, 20:02
 Arashekino re: More to the story.... Sep 4, 21:56
 Max re: More to the story.... Sep 5, 10:02
 Stephen B re: More to the story.... Sep 6, 02:17
Max re: More to the story.... Sep 6, 10:32
Men re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 17:34
Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 23:54
Jari Lievonen re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 12:31
Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 19:46
Jari Lievonen Oleg, think you missed the point Sep 1, 10:47
Oleg You might be right, but... Sep 1, 22:48
Henry Oster re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 8, 09:38
 Alejandro Parra re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 2, 05:30
 Stephen B re: I will argue differnt times but basically... (+) Sep 4, 20:33
Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 01:53
David Woolbright re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 07:58
 Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 19:37
Max re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 20:46
Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 22:50
 David Woolbright re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 04:19
Oleg Operation Bagration is... Sep 1, 22:41
 David Woolbright re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 08:05
 James Quinn Possible answer to this question Aug 31, 21:36
 Men re: Possible answer to this question Aug 31, 22:59
Mike Johnson re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 31, 22:57
 Oleg Agree 100% Aug 31, 23:09
  •  Stepan Mikhalik re: Agree 100% Sep 1, 04:59
     Barry Morrison re: Agree 100% Sep 2, 11:11
    Bogdanov WHAT ABOUT THE 1812 and Napoleon? (-) Sep 22, 20:55
  •  Lev re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 04:54
     Mr. L. L. re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 05:48
     Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 15:06
    Mike Johnson re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 18:48
     Mr. L. L. re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 2, 20:35
    Reigo re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 3, 00:44
     Sergei koptenko Reading from the same book Sep 4, 01:01
    Oleg Minor comment about the number of tanks Sep 5, 22:52
    Mike Johnson re: Minor comment about the number of tanks (+) Sep 6, 16:31
    Sergei K. re: Minor comment about the number of tanks Sep 7, 05:17
     Mike Johnson re: Minor comment about the number of tanks Sep 8, 00:01
    Anatoly re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 08:46
     Stepan Mikhalik Similarities Sep 1, 09:36
    Arashekino re: Cliches abound! Sep 1, 17:04
     Arashekino re: Cliches abound! Sep 1, 17:31
    Mike Johnson re: Cliches abound! Sep 1, 19:04
     David Woolbright re: Cliches abound! Sep 2, 01:53
     Stepan Mikhalik Wrong Wrong Wrong (+) Sep 2, 14:01
     Stepan Mikhalik re: Wrong Wrong Wrong Sep 2, 14:03
     Arashekino re: Wrong Wrong Wrong Sep 3, 02:54
     Stepan Mikhalik re: Wrong Wrong Wrong (+) Sep 3, 05:49
    Scott Fraser Well said! Everyone should read this! n/t (-) Sep 3, 06:36
     Arashekino re: right right right (+) Sep 3, 18:33
     Mark Jaremco Western and Eastern Ukrainians (+) Sep 4, 00:03
    Scott Fraser Babi Yar � A. Anatoly (Kuznetsov) (+) Sep 4, 01:07
    Mr. L. L. Babi Yar � A. Anatoly Fiction Sep 4, 21:53
    Scott Fraser re: Babi Yar � A. Anatoly Fiction Sep 4, 23:30
     Oleg re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 22:55
    Anatoly re: for Oleg Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 08:56
     Dan re: Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Sep 1, 22:45

    Threads navigation:  5 <<<  4  >>> 3

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1396, visitors today 1330, now 98