Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Carl-Fredrik Geust: re: Soviet FW-189s, Lightnings etc

A few remarks to this extremely interesting dirscussion. Misidentification seems to have happened in particular when new, previously unknown aircraft were introduced by one of the combattants. It should be remembered that the utmost was to keep the new aircraft, their origin and characterstics secret from the enemy, and the enemy aircraft identification tables used in all air forces are very elementary and erroneous as seen with todays eyes, when even small 10-year boys assembling exact plastic models are able to accurately identify all major combat aircraft and their subtypes.
Thus eg. following cases of misidentification on the Finnish-Soviet fronts can now be established:
- in Feb 1940 the AF of the Soviet Baltic Fleet (VVS KBF) reported numerous shot down Finnish "Spitfires" - which in fact were freshly delivered Morane 406s (all dates and locations coincide). (It should be noted that Finland had in fact requested Spitfires from England during the winter war, but only a dozen Hurricanes were ultimately delivered. It it quite possible that the Soviet intelligence got information about the Finnish-British negotiations concerning Spitfires, and that this in fact supported the sighting of "Spitfires").
- in Oct-Nov 1941 VVS KBF reported again "Spitfires" at Hanko, two of which were even shot down. This was in fact Curtiss 75-fighters of Osasto Berg, which were sent to Nummela (near Hanko) in order to eliminate the Soviet AF base, but with poor results. - How can then the misidentification of a radial-engine Curtiss for a Spit then be explained? - It should be remembered that Hanko was an isolated base, which probably no updated aircraft identification schemes - but the winter war "spitfire"- appearence well in memory. When now a previously unknown - and unseen fighter - Curtiss appeared, the conclusion was obviously made that now the Finns have sent their secret Spits to Hanko! (i have discussed this with the Soviet Hanko ace Vasily Golubev personally, who shoit down the two "Spits", but admitted that in 1941 he did not know for sure what a Spit did look like...
- it took also two years (until 1943) before the Soviet naval pilots were able to identify the Finnish Brewster (only in spring 1943 a Brewster was shot down at Oranienbaum enabling positive identification), while Soviet combat reports talk of all kind of radial engine fighters (Fokker D.21, Fiat G.50, Caproni, Seversky etc) when Brewster was in fact in question.
- also the new Yak-9s of fighter regiments of 275 IAD of 13th Air Army at the Karelian Isthmus were not properaly identified by the Finnish pilots but mistaken for "Mustangs".
- Finally Juutilainen's "Lightning": I must admit that I do not know, so far I have found no logical explanation. The Soviets did capture a number of servicable Fw 189s, but they were to my knowledge only tested at NII VVS (Research Institute of the Soviet Air Force) near Moscow, and not used operationally (see peictures in my books "Under the Red Star" and Red Stars Vol 2). I have tried to study this question in the Soviet naval archives, but without result so far.
The Soviets did however capture and test fly at least two Lightnings which obviously had force-landed in Hungary at the end of the war:
- 44-24384 "Blackie" (certainly flew with Red Stars in 1946), and
- 442421_ "Pride of Jane" (probably restored to flying condition).
I would be grateful if someone can tell me the history of these aircraft,
regards
Carl

1 September 2000, 00:53:56

2.  Clint Muse Soviet Lightnings Aug 28, 20:01

 Stephen B re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 29, 03:18
Tero Mistaken ID ? Aug 29, 08:10
gennady re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 29, 15:03
 Clint Muse re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 29, 16:10
 Juha re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 12:04
Scott Fraser re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 13:33
Jari Lievonen re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 15:17
Pentti Perttula re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 30, 15:39
 gennady re: Soviet Lightnings Aug 31, 15:46
 gennady re: Soviet FW-189s Aug 31, 17:25
  • Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Soviet FW-189s, Lightnings etc Sep 1, 00:53
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Soviet Lightnings Sep 1, 00:57
    gennady re: about score of Finnish and Soviet fighters (+) Sep 1, 18:31
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: about score of Finnish and Soviet fighters (+) Sep 1, 22:49
  •  Mirek Wawrzynski re: Soviet Lightnings, maybe it is true Sep 3, 16:09
    Carl-Fredrik Geust re: Soviet Lightnings, maybe it is true Sep 3, 16:25
    Krzysztof Pawlowski re: Soviet Lightnings, maybe it is true Sep 4, 21:11
     Clint Muse re: Lockheed P-322 Sep 5, 01:43

    Threads navigation:  3 <<<  2  >>> 1

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 1446, visitors today 1380, now 93