| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Yes, other Armies did suffer defeats but never before nor after had any other army suffered such terrible defeats as the Red Army in 1941 (one million perished or captured at Kiev alone). It is also true that the Red Army for the best part of the WW2 followed the same tactics the Russian Army used in 1914, i.e. stupid frontal mass assaults many times in a row in the same place. Just like most of Czarist officers Soviet ones showed tactical clumsiness, inflexibility and total insensitivity to mountains of own dead. No one knows how many million Russians died in the WWI and they are still argue how many millions died in the Second one. We also should not forget that in 1941 there were no commissars and no NKVD troops behind the lines mowing down anyone who tried to retreat. My question is was this higher 1941 tenacity of Soviet troops compared to 1941 partly due to higher degree of political coercion and terror in the Red Army of 1941. I said "partially", as no doubt most of it came from natural toughness of the Russian soldier
31 August 2000, 20:46:14
4.
James Quinn
Russian/Soviet responses to invasion. Aug 30, 17:26
Threads navigation: 5 <<< 4 >>> 3
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 1387, visitors today 1321, now 98 |