Forum Archive #4

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Tero:
re: distortions and embellishments ?

>It sounds like you have read some pretty wacky stuff. When was all this published?

1940's - 2000

>Just because a historian inserts some �hurray for our side,� material does not of necessity negate the value of the basic research gone into the work.

It does make the data search criteria and gueries made from it highly suspect.

>David Glantz and his peers use many Soviet histories in their research. They admit the they are run through with propaganda but that the military conclusions are valid and
survive extensive cross referencing. Likewise for western history.

Aboslutely not. People like Ziemke used almost exclusively Germans sources and his books were even proof read by the German generals, the very people (or their collegues) who had compiled the data in the first place during the war. You really think books like that give a historically accurate picture of the events, devoid of any ass covering, sour grapes or embellishments ? Mr. Glantz is in the vanguard of "proper" historians in the west who use source critique as it should be used. I would very much like to see him start digging the Western archives with in a similar fashion he has been digging the Soviet/Russian archives.

>If you will not trust any of the data and conclusions in all previous western works of history there is basis for us to debate.

It is not a matter of trust. It is a matter of not taking everything at face value or even with a pinch of salt. "It must be true because renowned historian N.N. says so" is not good enough for me.

>They lived through the time and would be in a better position due to their experience in the actualities of war to discern disinformation from truth.

So I might as well ask any Finnish veteran too ?

>Ah. So if I say that �my� side made a substantial contribution I am full of hot air and vinegar, but if I blow the Soviet horn and show how much of a sacrifice they made relying on their sources that�s OK.

Grow up. You need to start ...

>>> 

Tue Jul 18 15:14:22 2000


 TIM One true history,one true world (Jun, 28)
 Stephen (AC) Brezinski re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
 Vladimir Starostin re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
Scott Fraser If I Remember Correctly (Jun, 29)
Bob Potter re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 30)
Scott Fraser George and not Carlos? n/t (-) (Jun, 30)
Whitey Bulger It's spelled "SANTAYANA" & you're right, Bob (n/t) (-) (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
 Arashekino re: Truth is the first casualty of war! (Jun, 29)
 ANZAC Scott ... Brilliant (Jun, 29)
 Jorge Visca re: One true history,one true world (Jun, 29)
 Tero Happy to see it is not only the non-English speaking, ... (Jun, 29)
 Nick re:I AGREE..But ..... (Jun, 29)
Tero Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Men re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Tero Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
Men re: Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
 Men re: Nokia is doing fine, it is the ..... (Jun, 30)
 Nick re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
TIM re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Al re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 29)
Tero Revisionism is not allways bad (Jun, 30)
Scott Fraser re: Facts and opinions (Jun, 29)
Al re: Facts and opinions (Jun, 30)
Arashekino re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
Scott Fraser re: What is to be Done? � 1905 (Jun, 30)
 Nick re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
 Max re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
 Jorge Visca re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
 Men re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
 Jorge Visca re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jul, 1)
Men re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jun, 30)
 Arashekino re: Gangsters in Siberia!? (Jul, 1)
Whitey Bulger re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 2)
 Men re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 2)
 Jorge Visca re: Gangsters in Siberia!? - I have the answer! (Jul, 5)
 ... re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
 Max re: Where to begin...... (Jun, 30)
 Tristan re: Where to begin...... (Jul, 7)
Scott Fraser Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jun, 30)
 Max Most vital - Oil (Jun, 30)
Christer Bergstrom Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 3)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser re: Air superiority on the Eastern Front (Jul, 4)
Tero Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 5)
Scott Fraser re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 5)
Tero re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Tero re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 6)
 Jorge Visca re: Spitfire in the Eastern Front (Jul, 7)
Tero Yak-9 canopy vs Spitfire V canopy (Jul, 7)
Scott Fraser Spitfire wings (Jul, 7)
Tero re: Spitfire wings (Jul, 7)
Tero RAF 155 Sqn with Mk VIII's in Russia in 1943 ???!!!??? (Jul, 7)
Scott Fraser Hmmmm. (Jul, 7)
Tero re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 10)
Scott Fraser re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 11)
Tero re: Hmmmm. (Jul, 11)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 4)
Scott Fraser re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 4)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
Arashekino re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 6)
Scott Fraser re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 6)
 clarence morgan samuels (BDA) Bomb Damage Assessment (Jul, 5)
 Jorge Visca What POL stands for? (-) (Jul, 5)
JWB re: What POL stands for? (Jul, 6)
 Jorge Visca Thanks! (-) (Jul, 7)
 Tero Yes, but..... (Jul, 6)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
Tero re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Yes, but..... (Jul, 7)
Tero Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 10)
Scott Fraser Coal, steel and synthetic oil production (Jul, 11)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Coal, steel and synthetic oil production (Jul, 11)
 clarence morgan samuels re: Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 11)
Tero re: Sinister cover ups, distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 11)
 clarence morgan samuels distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
Tero re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
 clarence morgan samuels re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 12)
  • Tero re: distortions and embellishments ? (Jul, 18)
  • TIM re: Wartime Yankee propaganda lives! (Jul, 5)
    Wen Jin Western Propaganda (Jun, 30)
     Men re: Western Propaganda (Jul, 1)
    TIM re: Western Propaganda (Jul, 5)

    Records: 86

    Threads navigation:  prev <<<  >>> next 

    Russian Military ZoneSoviet Artillery 1920-1945Virtual Library
    Devoted to the Soviet and lend-lease tanks of the Second World War. Detailed info about each vehicle, many interesting pictures and photos! Devoted to the Soviet artillery, ammunition and other supplemental stuff. You'll find there a lot of useful and rare information as well as archive documents, orders and tables. Contains tones of archival documents related to the Second World War and beyond. You'll find there a lot of rare info about Soviet Army, industry and diplomacy of the Soviet Government.